ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--For all its seemingly convincing ubiquity and organisational power, there’s something perceptively phoney about the National Resistance Movement, NRM: an aura of some inexplicable oddity that the party just seems unable to shake off.
Yes, exteriorly, the NRM, currently in power, makes an impression of strength, institutional order and focus, observers say. But for any ruling party, it’s pretty easy to project that impression and NRM’s overwhelming presence might be of little help to anyone trying to weight its real worth. In fact its real test will come when it faces the challenge of surviving the political demise of the founding chairman, Mr. Yoweri Museveni.
Although the NRM is young and has a lot to do to transform itself into a functioning, robust and sustainable entity there’s little that has been achieved in the way of building the party’s internal capacity. There are so many basics that have eluded it thus far that make political observers fret about its ability to survive a change of government in Uganda.
All through the past elections and other party activities, the NRM has counted on Mr Museveni to mobilise all the requisite funds and there has not been any discernible effort on the part of the party leadership to develop lasting and institutionalised mechanisms of generating money to fund its spending needs. Plans to acquire some properties that could in future fund the organisation have badly foundered for the party’s lifetime to date and there isn’t any sign the party’s troubled finances might improve in the foreseeable future, foreshadowing a dark time when its current fundraiser-in-chief exits.
An August 27th analysis last year in Daily Monitor of the NRM’s ailments serves as a microcosm of the terrible fate that might strike this party in a post-Museveni Uganda. The story for instance quoted a source who claimed that the NRM’s landlord had threatened to eject it from its headquarters on No. 10 Kyadodo Road, after it had piled up rent arrears and repeatedly ratted on its promise to clear them—a deeply mortifying episode for a party projected by its Chairman as formidable. It doesn’t help matters that its equally financially struggling (but humbler) rival, FDC can afford its rent.
In fact the threat on the Headquarters was emblematic of a broader crisis, with nearly all of NRM’s district offices reportedly abandoned by broke officials or evicted for failure to pay rent. Several party officials who spoke anonymously in that story voiced intense frustration that Mr Museveni was personally influencing the activities, direction and policy of the party from his base at State House, circumventing all the party executives and organs.
It is these perpetual financial woes, unilateral decision making by the party chairman and unremitting internal turmoil that makes the NRM increasingly look fated to fade with the exit of President Museveni.
To the ex legislator, Mr Agrey Awori the NRM edifice is evidently tenuous, but it still “could survive the political demise of Mr Museveni depending on whether he grooms strong personalities.”
If that were to be the case though, Mr Museveni would have to radically shift his style of leadership and management of the party affairs so that institutional structures are allowed to function unhindered and charismatic party members offered an opportunity to shine. However, apparently there’s no sign Museveni is changing his style of governing the party and, instead, all telltales point to a hardening of his strong-man leadership approach and a weakening of NRM’s formal organs.
Mr Awori for example bemoaned the virtual isolation of the party vice chairman, Mr Al Haji Moses Kigongo and portrayed it as signalling a troubling trend.
A recent NRM convert, Mr Awori, too, said the escalating factionalism and nasty ego clashes amongst the party stalwarts was “unhealthy” and that “mafia allegations” could deal the party a deadly blow in the event of change of government. Another source within the NRM, suggested there was effectively no one running the party now since, “Museveni is busy with the presidency, Mbabazi (Party Secretary General) with political intelligence and Kigongo marginalised.”
A few party members are placing hope in half a dozen or so young NRM leaders who have recently shown a measure of circumspection and broad appeal to inspire genuine change in the party.
In December 2006, four zealous young NRM MPs: Frank Tumwebaze, Margaret Muhanga, David Bahati and Mr. Chris Baryomunsi, co-authored a paper that assailed Mr Museveni for failing to acknowledge the factors eroding his support, culminating in his all-time low 59% vote in the February 2006 presidential elections.
It was the first time NRM members without any influence or power, had directly criticised Mr Museveni who had hitherto enjoyed a de facto sacred cow status in the party. While immediately not of any profound significance, that incident was noted by analysts as capable of inspiring future determination on the part of other members who may feel dissatisfied by Mr Museveni’s uncompromising leadership to directly engage him.
In an interview, Mr. Baryomunsi stated that the NRM was currently “struggling very hard” to decouple the NRM from its chairman, Mr Museveni and also accepted it as imperative for the party to outgrow the culture of “historicals.” Still, for all the mounting crises undermining the NRM’s integrity, Baryomunsi believes it can float on in a Post-Museveni Uganda. The key, he asserted, will be “how we exercise internal democracy and elect leaders.”
THE history of political parties and their fortunes after their leaders have left power in Uganda appears to particularly bode ill for the NRM. By any comparison, the NRM has arguably not reached even half the might, mass appeal and financial capacity of two of the historical parties: Obote-founded Uganda Peoples Congress and the Democratic Party, DP at the peak of their power. And yet, over the last 20 years those parties have helplessly declined to sad relics of their past selves.
With its administrative structures particularly at the district and lower levels tenuous or non-existent, perpetually empty coffers, continuous wrangling in senior party ranks and rising dispassion in the party’s rank and file, an intransigent party chairman: the NRM organisation might as well write its epilogue soonest after Museveni’s end.
Friday, June 6, 2008
Thursday, May 15, 2008
Common Denominator in Mr. Museveni’s Industrialisation Rhetoric.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
KAMPALA--President Museveni and a shrinking brigade of his die-hard loyalists within the NRM routinely harp about industrialising Uganda—something so basic a primary pupil would discuss it with an effort no more than he needs to lick candy—as though the subject were esoteric.
In fact, Museveni pursues his industrialisation crusades with such fervour it’s as if he invented the concept, fooling many into believing that he has an honest interest into expanding Uganda’s manufacturing capacity and thrusting the country into a modern age.
And yet Museveni and his NRM’s rants about building Uganda’s industrial capacity are mere gimmickry contrived to con Ugandans into swallowing assertions that the administration is spending our taxpayer money to transform the country when actually they are busying themselves with primitive accumulation evident in the mounting corruption epidemic.
One stark example— the infamous Tri-Star Apparels firm—bares the deception of Mr Museveni and his NRM’s proclamations on industrialisation and the immense harm they have done to this country under a clever guise of transforming it.
If there was any generous chance for this administration to demonstrate its commitment to uplifting this country, it was the African Growth and Opportunity Act, Agoa, the law enacted by the US Congress in early 2000 to let impoverished African nations like Uganda export, unencumbered by quotas and tariffs, cheap goods to the US market.
There are dozens of goods eligible for export under Agoa, but there’s only one area where Uganda had a breathtaking advantage—organic cotton production—and the country, if well led, should have become a mass producer of nice garments for both the US domestic markets. But a sadistic government, the NRM, would not let us be what we wanna be (to borrow a phrase from the American rapper, Nas’ song: I Can) and instead seized what was a profound, historic opportunity and turned it into what FDC’s Dr. Col. (rdt) Kizza Besigye famously described as a “costly fiasco.”
Before we could brink, instead of the thousands of jobs and millions of precious dollars in export earnings we had been promised by Mr Museveni while haranguing us to embrace Agoa: Shs 24 billion of scarce taxes had been made to disappear through a corrupt nexus, whose public face was a Sri Lankan shark, Mr Vellupilai Kananathan but whose masterminds appeared stationed around Nakasero.
These days whenever Mr Museveni is challenged about his reckless destruction of this nation through displacement of public institutions to give the land to his purported investors, he berates us for not appreciating the need for industrialisation and, well, lacking vision.
But the Tri-star Apparel swindle showed the nation what in fact Mr. Museveni has in mind when he speaks of industrialisation—a pipeline to siphon off the nation’s taxes by those that have a “vision.” This is what we should always have in mind whenever Mr Museveni takes to the podium and launches into his lectures on boosting Uganda’s industrial capacity.
And when we grasp this important connection between the numerous industrialisation/modernisation projects (Tri Star, Mabira giveaway, former UTV land, Shimoni land, Kalangala forests for oil palms etc) and the endless loop of loss to the taxpayer, it will become easy for us to comprehend some of the most bizarre acts like the looming despoliation of the source of River Nile.
Uganda’s Founding Father, ex President Dr. Milton Obote once arrived at an accurate characterisation of Mr Museveni (as a violent man) by rooting for a constant factor in all of the wars where Museveni has been involved. He observed that the theatres and times of those wars had been varied as had been the causes and several other aspects. Only two elements remained strikingly constant: Mr Museveni and the atrocities against non-combatants.
That’s a helpful clue to understanding today’s Mr Museveni and his supposed efforts to expand industrial production in Uganda. Over the time he has been pressing this cause: the projects, years, investors involved, sectors etc, have been different. Only two elements that have not varied whatsoever throughout: Mr Museveni and the loop of loss to the taxpayer.
There’s no gainsaying that Uganda needs industries. We need to create formal jobs for the hordes of youth streaming out of universities. We need to expand our technological capacity. these are no small tasks and if there were any Asian, Arab, European, American or any person of any race or from any region willing to come and lend a hand in efforts to realise these achievements, that person deserves maximum goodwill and support from us citizens and our government.
Nevertheless, when Mr Museveni and his NRM start to switch public land from this use to that and lavish incentives to investors: it is time to start worrying by any one who knows those two common denominators in this administration’s industrialisation effort
KAMPALA--President Museveni and a shrinking brigade of his die-hard loyalists within the NRM routinely harp about industrialising Uganda—something so basic a primary pupil would discuss it with an effort no more than he needs to lick candy—as though the subject were esoteric.
In fact, Museveni pursues his industrialisation crusades with such fervour it’s as if he invented the concept, fooling many into believing that he has an honest interest into expanding Uganda’s manufacturing capacity and thrusting the country into a modern age.
And yet Museveni and his NRM’s rants about building Uganda’s industrial capacity are mere gimmickry contrived to con Ugandans into swallowing assertions that the administration is spending our taxpayer money to transform the country when actually they are busying themselves with primitive accumulation evident in the mounting corruption epidemic.
One stark example— the infamous Tri-Star Apparels firm—bares the deception of Mr Museveni and his NRM’s proclamations on industrialisation and the immense harm they have done to this country under a clever guise of transforming it.
If there was any generous chance for this administration to demonstrate its commitment to uplifting this country, it was the African Growth and Opportunity Act, Agoa, the law enacted by the US Congress in early 2000 to let impoverished African nations like Uganda export, unencumbered by quotas and tariffs, cheap goods to the US market.
There are dozens of goods eligible for export under Agoa, but there’s only one area where Uganda had a breathtaking advantage—organic cotton production—and the country, if well led, should have become a mass producer of nice garments for both the US domestic markets. But a sadistic government, the NRM, would not let us be what we wanna be (to borrow a phrase from the American rapper, Nas’ song: I Can) and instead seized what was a profound, historic opportunity and turned it into what FDC’s Dr. Col. (rdt) Kizza Besigye famously described as a “costly fiasco.”
Before we could brink, instead of the thousands of jobs and millions of precious dollars in export earnings we had been promised by Mr Museveni while haranguing us to embrace Agoa: Shs 24 billion of scarce taxes had been made to disappear through a corrupt nexus, whose public face was a Sri Lankan shark, Mr Vellupilai Kananathan but whose masterminds appeared stationed around Nakasero.
These days whenever Mr Museveni is challenged about his reckless destruction of this nation through displacement of public institutions to give the land to his purported investors, he berates us for not appreciating the need for industrialisation and, well, lacking vision.
But the Tri-star Apparel swindle showed the nation what in fact Mr. Museveni has in mind when he speaks of industrialisation—a pipeline to siphon off the nation’s taxes by those that have a “vision.” This is what we should always have in mind whenever Mr Museveni takes to the podium and launches into his lectures on boosting Uganda’s industrial capacity.
And when we grasp this important connection between the numerous industrialisation/modernisation projects (Tri Star, Mabira giveaway, former UTV land, Shimoni land, Kalangala forests for oil palms etc) and the endless loop of loss to the taxpayer, it will become easy for us to comprehend some of the most bizarre acts like the looming despoliation of the source of River Nile.
Uganda’s Founding Father, ex President Dr. Milton Obote once arrived at an accurate characterisation of Mr Museveni (as a violent man) by rooting for a constant factor in all of the wars where Museveni has been involved. He observed that the theatres and times of those wars had been varied as had been the causes and several other aspects. Only two elements remained strikingly constant: Mr Museveni and the atrocities against non-combatants.
That’s a helpful clue to understanding today’s Mr Museveni and his supposed efforts to expand industrial production in Uganda. Over the time he has been pressing this cause: the projects, years, investors involved, sectors etc, have been different. Only two elements that have not varied whatsoever throughout: Mr Museveni and the loop of loss to the taxpayer.
There’s no gainsaying that Uganda needs industries. We need to create formal jobs for the hordes of youth streaming out of universities. We need to expand our technological capacity. these are no small tasks and if there were any Asian, Arab, European, American or any person of any race or from any region willing to come and lend a hand in efforts to realise these achievements, that person deserves maximum goodwill and support from us citizens and our government.
Nevertheless, when Mr Museveni and his NRM start to switch public land from this use to that and lavish incentives to investors: it is time to start worrying by any one who knows those two common denominators in this administration’s industrialisation effort
Friday, April 25, 2008
Global Food Crisis and President Museveni's Populist View
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
KAMPALA--Just about every body round here and across the globe agrees the escalating food prices are fomenting a new world pandemic, that will unsettle societies and spawn desperation and death.
As it appears, the logic is pretty simple: costly food will increasingly slip out of the reach of millions of poor folks already struggling to survive daily. Mass starvation will consume millions. And as the civil unrest erupting in several countries has demonstrated, the consequences of this spreading hunger can be far reaching.
Only one man is smiling through all this global food melancholy—President Yoweri Museveni.
Always a contrarian, his supposedly unfailing wisdom ahead of everybody’s, Mr Museveni was reported on NTV’s Tonight news programme recently claiming that far from being saddened, he was revelling in the runaway food prices. For once, he said, his peasants, long tormented by bottom earnings from their produce, were going to get rich.
Glibly, his political assistant, Mr Moses Byaruhanga chorused the same assertion. It is hard to understand why Mr Museveni should be making such an embarrassingly populist claim.
True, Uganda produces a number of foods—beef, rice, sugar, corn (maize) etc— whose world supplies are running critically low and it is easy to construct a simplistic argument that the rise in the prices of these foods is good for Uganda.
But that would be farcical.
Although accurate figures are hard to find, Uganda is believed to be a net food importer and any steep upswing in the cost of food will easily deteriorate our trade deficit, and potentially rattle the larger economy. Uganda’s agriculture is nearly all of it subsistence, and there’s little the country’s peasants—barely able to feed themselves even in the best of times, to say nothing of exporting—can benefit from the soaring world food prices.
Yes, a peasant here and there, with extended acreage under cultivation, will rake in a few extra shillings but that’s a blip compared to the deadly hunger that could grip urbanites and the mass starvation awaiting the millions in North and Eastern Uganda that rely on relief food daily if the rocketing prices are not curbed.
In fact, even if these prices go on to engender a crisis in Kampala and other urban centres, a large section of the peasant families, who daily scrimp by on remittances from their richer, urban-dwelling relatives, will get sucked up in the pandemic as those relatives spend all they earn on the costly food. A great deal of the food consumed across Uganda is imported: wheat, corn, rice, cooking oil etc. I can’t seem to see any obvious winners in this food price scourge—it’s all a lose-lose situation.
In fact, more than any other leader, President Museveni should worry: 1.6million of his citizens, trapped in displacement camps in North and North East Uganda, are fed by WFP, mostly on imported food—corn, cooking oil, wheat flour etc. As the prices rise, WFP’s budget will only be able to purchase lesser and lesser food and the rations are already being cut as the body’s donors are unwilling or slow in responding to appeals for more generosity. And even if WFP were purchasing the food from Uganda, the supply scarcities would still spark immense suffering despite a windfall for the middlemen and may be some peasants. Diluted by the price hikes, the WFP’s budget would only cover a fraction of its normal food purchase levels, meaning hunger in the bellies of millions in Uganda whose mouths it caters.
And that’s before we even start to think of the dreadful consequences of starvation in Kampala and other municipalities across the country. Already unable to cope with the ever increasing hordes of poor, sudden starvation would stir nothing short of upheaval, a crisis the NRM can hardly handle. Gloomily, too, the NRM, never a government to plan for contingencies, runs the nation without strategic food reserves and so all it takes is a mere slight jolt to a normal food flow to plunge Uganda into a full-blown catastrophe. The ballooning food supply crisis could offer that jolt.
If Mr Museveni were right and food prices were good for peasant nations, West African countries, which like us have plenty of them, would not be erupting. And yet governments there have had to mass police forces on the streets to quell hunger-stoked explosions of violence.
So how, then, minding all the foregoing could Museveni start celebrating the global food price surge?
It’s a noxious blend of populist politics, mendacity and plain incompetence that have come to define the NRM lately. His predictions of bonanzas for peasants, false and absurd as they are, are easily believed by the NRM’s core constituency—the naïve rural masses. And obviously unprepared to absorb the impact a food crisis, the populist declarations of the supposed bonanza helps Mr Museveni sooth a fretful and agitated populace.
KAMPALA--Just about every body round here and across the globe agrees the escalating food prices are fomenting a new world pandemic, that will unsettle societies and spawn desperation and death.
As it appears, the logic is pretty simple: costly food will increasingly slip out of the reach of millions of poor folks already struggling to survive daily. Mass starvation will consume millions. And as the civil unrest erupting in several countries has demonstrated, the consequences of this spreading hunger can be far reaching.
Only one man is smiling through all this global food melancholy—President Yoweri Museveni.
Always a contrarian, his supposedly unfailing wisdom ahead of everybody’s, Mr Museveni was reported on NTV’s Tonight news programme recently claiming that far from being saddened, he was revelling in the runaway food prices. For once, he said, his peasants, long tormented by bottom earnings from their produce, were going to get rich.
Glibly, his political assistant, Mr Moses Byaruhanga chorused the same assertion. It is hard to understand why Mr Museveni should be making such an embarrassingly populist claim.
True, Uganda produces a number of foods—beef, rice, sugar, corn (maize) etc— whose world supplies are running critically low and it is easy to construct a simplistic argument that the rise in the prices of these foods is good for Uganda.
But that would be farcical.
Although accurate figures are hard to find, Uganda is believed to be a net food importer and any steep upswing in the cost of food will easily deteriorate our trade deficit, and potentially rattle the larger economy. Uganda’s agriculture is nearly all of it subsistence, and there’s little the country’s peasants—barely able to feed themselves even in the best of times, to say nothing of exporting—can benefit from the soaring world food prices.
Yes, a peasant here and there, with extended acreage under cultivation, will rake in a few extra shillings but that’s a blip compared to the deadly hunger that could grip urbanites and the mass starvation awaiting the millions in North and Eastern Uganda that rely on relief food daily if the rocketing prices are not curbed.
In fact, even if these prices go on to engender a crisis in Kampala and other urban centres, a large section of the peasant families, who daily scrimp by on remittances from their richer, urban-dwelling relatives, will get sucked up in the pandemic as those relatives spend all they earn on the costly food. A great deal of the food consumed across Uganda is imported: wheat, corn, rice, cooking oil etc. I can’t seem to see any obvious winners in this food price scourge—it’s all a lose-lose situation.
In fact, more than any other leader, President Museveni should worry: 1.6million of his citizens, trapped in displacement camps in North and North East Uganda, are fed by WFP, mostly on imported food—corn, cooking oil, wheat flour etc. As the prices rise, WFP’s budget will only be able to purchase lesser and lesser food and the rations are already being cut as the body’s donors are unwilling or slow in responding to appeals for more generosity. And even if WFP were purchasing the food from Uganda, the supply scarcities would still spark immense suffering despite a windfall for the middlemen and may be some peasants. Diluted by the price hikes, the WFP’s budget would only cover a fraction of its normal food purchase levels, meaning hunger in the bellies of millions in Uganda whose mouths it caters.
And that’s before we even start to think of the dreadful consequences of starvation in Kampala and other municipalities across the country. Already unable to cope with the ever increasing hordes of poor, sudden starvation would stir nothing short of upheaval, a crisis the NRM can hardly handle. Gloomily, too, the NRM, never a government to plan for contingencies, runs the nation without strategic food reserves and so all it takes is a mere slight jolt to a normal food flow to plunge Uganda into a full-blown catastrophe. The ballooning food supply crisis could offer that jolt.
If Mr Museveni were right and food prices were good for peasant nations, West African countries, which like us have plenty of them, would not be erupting. And yet governments there have had to mass police forces on the streets to quell hunger-stoked explosions of violence.
So how, then, minding all the foregoing could Museveni start celebrating the global food price surge?
It’s a noxious blend of populist politics, mendacity and plain incompetence that have come to define the NRM lately. His predictions of bonanzas for peasants, false and absurd as they are, are easily believed by the NRM’s core constituency—the naïve rural masses. And obviously unprepared to absorb the impact a food crisis, the populist declarations of the supposed bonanza helps Mr Museveni sooth a fretful and agitated populace.
Strange Encounter: Clean African City!
Kigali, April 13—few experiences are as refreshing as meeting a Sub-Saharan African city or town that comes close to typifying what a city should be.
Kigali is that.
From the grassy, beautifully manicured medians to the unfailing traffic lights, to the smooth road network to the absolute civil order across the city, Kigali brings profound warmth to the heart.
A tiny city of little commerce, a thin population and an unremarkable skyline, Kigali makes up for all that stunning lack of sophistication with its breathtaking neatness, civil discipline and administrative efficiency.
If to visit down-town Kampala is to be in hell and back, a visit to Kigali is a visit to Heaven.
The contrast is stark as that! That Rwanda, a tiny, extraordinarily poor nation that’s still eclipsed by its genocidal horrors, can marshal its minute efforts and construct an organised and sensible city and all Uganda’s NRM can do—with the vast resources at its disposal—is manage a garbage-strewn, flood-swathed Kampala is one of the most numbing paradoxes of our time.
Thursday, March 20, 2008
Bank of Uganda: Violated Under Museveni, Its Future is Troubling.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--In November 2006, the FDC leader, Col. (rtd) Dr Kiiza Besigye made public stunning Bank of Uganda, BoU, confidential documents he had obtained exclusively; revealing for the first time, according to Besigye, President Yoweri Museveni directly violating laws that shield BoU from political influence.
The documents that involved several internal BoU and Finance ministry correspondences and a letter by Mr Museveni showed how he personally directed the BoU Governor, Mr Tumusiime Mutebile to use money meant for servicing a European Investment Bank, EIB, development loan to salvage a collapsing company belonging to a crony, Mr Hassan Basajja Balaba.
Basjja Balaba Hides and Skins, the company in question, was threatened with foreclosure by its creditor Standard Chartered Bank and the BoU, under Mr Museveni’s pressure, used money from the so called Apex Reflows Account which was part of the Consolidated Fund to pay the company’s Shs 20 billion loan.
This revelation was extraordinary in many ways but most importantly it offered the public a surprising window into the storied and befogged edifice that is BoU. At once it revealed a troubling vulnerability to politics that many people had never thought of, trusting as they did in the robust constitutional protection against executive interference in the Central Bank’s performance of its obligations.
That naivety might seem excusable. Exteriorly BoU has for long projected an image that innocently resembled what in fact the institution should be —a Central Bank acting independently to manage the country’s financial system and microeconomic stability. There was scarcely any hint the Bank had become deeply enmeshed in Mr Museveni’s far-reaching web of political patronage and Besigye’s astonishing disclosures led many to take in some heavy breath, unable to comprehend what they were reading.
And yet the Basajja scandal, even with its record-setting scale, seemed to be the tip of the iceberg—a fact that was underscored by FDC’s call for an inquiry into the (mis)management of the Consolidated Fund for the last ten years. And as if to affirm the urgency of FDC’s call, as the full length of the Basajja swindle was still unfolding, it was also coming to light that BoU had also lost over Shs 24 billion in politically-influenced loan guarantees to a bogus Sri Lankan textiles investor, Mr Velupillai Kananathan of Tri-Star Apparels.
While BoU is supposed to operate independently, behind-the-scenes president Museveni has pulled the levers, with its working bearing his imprint in ways far more extensive that most people realise or may ever believe. Getting his wishes implemented by BoU has been particularly easy, in a large part due to what you may call “friendly forces.”
It’s worth noting that the director of BoU’s Development Finance Department, which was administering the Apex Reflows money was Naomi Nasasira—wife of Eng. John Nasasira. Mr Nasasira is Mr Museveni’s Minister for Works and Transport and one of his fierce loyalists and longest-serving cabinet members.
And this hidden but strong relationship between the Central Bank and President Museveni, which is setting odious precedents, will deeply impact on this institution’s future functioning and partly determine how Mr Museveni’s successor government might relate to it.
Will BoU be able to recapture its diminished integrity in a post-Museveni Uganda? Can it regain its constitutional autonomy and execute its mandate free from the corrupting influence of the executive? If Uganda’s political actors and general population is disgusted with Mr Museveni and his thieving NRM regime and is looking forward to a hopeful post-Museveni Uganda: these will be some of the questions that will have to be pondered, particularly in the wider and vital debate of ideas on how to rejuvenate and clean up key state institutions.
BoU’s spending of the money that was subsequently lost to Basajja and Tri Star was as reckless as it was illegal. Parliament and the Auditor General, two authorities supposed to monitor and authorise all drawings on the Consolidated Fund never sanctioned it.
A researcher at Makerere University-based Economic Policy Research Centre, Mr Lawrence Bategeka reasoned that while Mr Museveni has not been exemplary in guarding BoU’s independence, neither has he sought to ride roughshod over it.
“I can’t see any single incident when Mr Museveni has flagrantly violated the independence of the Central Bank,” he said. Even when he has intervened, Mr Bategeka said, it has been largely to use it to influence the course of the nation’s economic policy when he thought it had derailed.
Central Banks for instance, according to Mr Bategeka, have long expanded their role from their traditional focus on the narrow aspects of financial regulation, interest rates and inflation to wider areas like spurring economic growth and development. That shift has meant that BoU’s can intervene actively to for instance stimulate the economy to create more jobs or buoy up distressed firms, something that may justify Mr Museveni’s influence of BoU and its spending of taxpayer money.
Such reasoning however would overlook troubling details. True, it might appear reasonable for Mr Museveni to use BoU to intervene in stabilising macroeconomic issues but not when he’s doing it illegally.
Secondly, even as it is being cast as benign, Mr Museveni’s breach of the independence of BoU might entice him (if it hasn’t already) into using the Central Bank to execute politically populist and imprudent economic programmes. Such a legacy might get entrenched by a future leader with disastrous consequences for the reputation of the Central Bank and the wider economy.
Deputy Secretary to Treasury, Mr Keith Muhakanizi argued in an interview that Mr Museveni actually is empowered by the constitution to act the way he did in the Basajja and Tri-Star disasters, describing his directives to BoU as “a policy matter.”
He, too, was cold to suggestions of Museveni’s interference with BoU, noting that if there had been any mismanagement of the Consolidated Fund, it was caused by bureaucrats acting on their own. “The problem is that when these people (public servants) fail or are caught in the wrong then they want to shift responsibility,” he said.
The letters from Mr Museveni to the Governor of BoU that Mr Besigye exposed though hardly corroborates Mr Muhakanizi’s assertions.
To be sure, Mr Museveni’s irregular dealings with the Central Bank have not been epidemic and they do not seem to be out of the bounds of aberrations that Ugandans have come to expect from the NRM administration. Nevertheless, if BoU doesn’t fight to retrieve its slipping independence, it could easily succumb to worse manipulation in a post-Museveni Uganda, foreshadowing disaster for the economy.
Kampala--In November 2006, the FDC leader, Col. (rtd) Dr Kiiza Besigye made public stunning Bank of Uganda, BoU, confidential documents he had obtained exclusively; revealing for the first time, according to Besigye, President Yoweri Museveni directly violating laws that shield BoU from political influence.
The documents that involved several internal BoU and Finance ministry correspondences and a letter by Mr Museveni showed how he personally directed the BoU Governor, Mr Tumusiime Mutebile to use money meant for servicing a European Investment Bank, EIB, development loan to salvage a collapsing company belonging to a crony, Mr Hassan Basajja Balaba.
Basjja Balaba Hides and Skins, the company in question, was threatened with foreclosure by its creditor Standard Chartered Bank and the BoU, under Mr Museveni’s pressure, used money from the so called Apex Reflows Account which was part of the Consolidated Fund to pay the company’s Shs 20 billion loan.
This revelation was extraordinary in many ways but most importantly it offered the public a surprising window into the storied and befogged edifice that is BoU. At once it revealed a troubling vulnerability to politics that many people had never thought of, trusting as they did in the robust constitutional protection against executive interference in the Central Bank’s performance of its obligations.
That naivety might seem excusable. Exteriorly BoU has for long projected an image that innocently resembled what in fact the institution should be —a Central Bank acting independently to manage the country’s financial system and microeconomic stability. There was scarcely any hint the Bank had become deeply enmeshed in Mr Museveni’s far-reaching web of political patronage and Besigye’s astonishing disclosures led many to take in some heavy breath, unable to comprehend what they were reading.
And yet the Basajja scandal, even with its record-setting scale, seemed to be the tip of the iceberg—a fact that was underscored by FDC’s call for an inquiry into the (mis)management of the Consolidated Fund for the last ten years. And as if to affirm the urgency of FDC’s call, as the full length of the Basajja swindle was still unfolding, it was also coming to light that BoU had also lost over Shs 24 billion in politically-influenced loan guarantees to a bogus Sri Lankan textiles investor, Mr Velupillai Kananathan of Tri-Star Apparels.
While BoU is supposed to operate independently, behind-the-scenes president Museveni has pulled the levers, with its working bearing his imprint in ways far more extensive that most people realise or may ever believe. Getting his wishes implemented by BoU has been particularly easy, in a large part due to what you may call “friendly forces.”
It’s worth noting that the director of BoU’s Development Finance Department, which was administering the Apex Reflows money was Naomi Nasasira—wife of Eng. John Nasasira. Mr Nasasira is Mr Museveni’s Minister for Works and Transport and one of his fierce loyalists and longest-serving cabinet members.
And this hidden but strong relationship between the Central Bank and President Museveni, which is setting odious precedents, will deeply impact on this institution’s future functioning and partly determine how Mr Museveni’s successor government might relate to it.
Will BoU be able to recapture its diminished integrity in a post-Museveni Uganda? Can it regain its constitutional autonomy and execute its mandate free from the corrupting influence of the executive? If Uganda’s political actors and general population is disgusted with Mr Museveni and his thieving NRM regime and is looking forward to a hopeful post-Museveni Uganda: these will be some of the questions that will have to be pondered, particularly in the wider and vital debate of ideas on how to rejuvenate and clean up key state institutions.
BoU’s spending of the money that was subsequently lost to Basajja and Tri Star was as reckless as it was illegal. Parliament and the Auditor General, two authorities supposed to monitor and authorise all drawings on the Consolidated Fund never sanctioned it.
A researcher at Makerere University-based Economic Policy Research Centre, Mr Lawrence Bategeka reasoned that while Mr Museveni has not been exemplary in guarding BoU’s independence, neither has he sought to ride roughshod over it.
“I can’t see any single incident when Mr Museveni has flagrantly violated the independence of the Central Bank,” he said. Even when he has intervened, Mr Bategeka said, it has been largely to use it to influence the course of the nation’s economic policy when he thought it had derailed.
Central Banks for instance, according to Mr Bategeka, have long expanded their role from their traditional focus on the narrow aspects of financial regulation, interest rates and inflation to wider areas like spurring economic growth and development. That shift has meant that BoU’s can intervene actively to for instance stimulate the economy to create more jobs or buoy up distressed firms, something that may justify Mr Museveni’s influence of BoU and its spending of taxpayer money.
Such reasoning however would overlook troubling details. True, it might appear reasonable for Mr Museveni to use BoU to intervene in stabilising macroeconomic issues but not when he’s doing it illegally.
Secondly, even as it is being cast as benign, Mr Museveni’s breach of the independence of BoU might entice him (if it hasn’t already) into using the Central Bank to execute politically populist and imprudent economic programmes. Such a legacy might get entrenched by a future leader with disastrous consequences for the reputation of the Central Bank and the wider economy.
Deputy Secretary to Treasury, Mr Keith Muhakanizi argued in an interview that Mr Museveni actually is empowered by the constitution to act the way he did in the Basajja and Tri-Star disasters, describing his directives to BoU as “a policy matter.”
He, too, was cold to suggestions of Museveni’s interference with BoU, noting that if there had been any mismanagement of the Consolidated Fund, it was caused by bureaucrats acting on their own. “The problem is that when these people (public servants) fail or are caught in the wrong then they want to shift responsibility,” he said.
The letters from Mr Museveni to the Governor of BoU that Mr Besigye exposed though hardly corroborates Mr Muhakanizi’s assertions.
To be sure, Mr Museveni’s irregular dealings with the Central Bank have not been epidemic and they do not seem to be out of the bounds of aberrations that Ugandans have come to expect from the NRM administration. Nevertheless, if BoU doesn’t fight to retrieve its slipping independence, it could easily succumb to worse manipulation in a post-Museveni Uganda, foreshadowing disaster for the economy.
Tuesday, March 11, 2008
UPDF in a Post-Museveni Uganda: Hints of Hope and Upheaval.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--From its founding in 1981, through the guerrilla battles to the seizure of power in ’86, transformation into a national army and then on to the current multiparty politics, the UPDF (formerly, NRA) has been run as a de facto personal army of President Yoweri Museveni.
Mr Museveni’s influence within the UPDF is so pervasive and overweening—or so he has made people believe—that most Ugandans have long understood it as nearly impossible for this institution to stand without him. And so there is a considerable measure of wonder and apprehension about the sort and extent of change, if any, that will sweep through the UPDF in a post-Museveni Uganda.
While it is true that the army has long shed some of its historical ties to Mr. Museveni and assumed a national character and visage, it still maintains lots of cultish loyalty and reverence for its founder and a great deal of the army command structures and functioning appear to spin around his personal authority that its unclear how that institution’s integrity will continue when its supposed centre of gravity (Mr Museveni) erodes.
In Ex Army Commander, Major Gen Mugisha Muntu’s prognosis, the UPDF can survive Mr Museveni’s political demise and grow even stronger but that that will depend on the evolving character of the force and factors influencing its internal growth and transformation.
There’s a growing cadreship of elite officers (highly educated, trained and modernist in outlook), Muntu observed, that is increasingly gravitating toward independent thinking and action and that if the future of UPDF is shaped by these officers then worries of an institutional breakdown after Museveni would be wanton. “Yes, they’re all these educated and inspiring officers in our military that are upcoming,” he said. “I think they represent the hope and continuity of our army.”
Encouragingly, too, the elongated stability of Uganda’s politics and the growing strength of some of the country’s democratic institutions and the spread of civil liberties—parliament, opposition parties, the media, civil society—is also cited by analysts to be quietly shaping the mindsets and general character of these officers. Increasingly a growing section within the military leadership, according to a source in the intelligence community, is inevitably realising that the army has little choice but to defend these young institutions and this epiphany will ultimately determine how the military behaves upon the exit of the founding Commander-in-Chief.
Be that as it may, plenty of hints here and there do not seem to point to a reassuring future. Another source within Mr. Museveni’s intelligence circle lamented the president’s persistent use of the army in his personal political manoeuvres, noting that the practise has now become so entrenched that it will take a long time to reverse.
In all the elections Uganda has had for instance under Mr Museveni—1996, 2001, 2006—the army has inserted itself (or has been inserted) right at the centre, with several senior raking officers actively conducting covert campaigns for President Museveni. The current coordinator of Intelligence Services, Mr David Tinyefuza and Maj. Gen Elly Tumwine overtly campaigned for President Museveni in 2001 and issued dreadful threats against his key opponent Col. Dr Kiiza Besigye. The same was reprised in 2006 elections.
For the UPDF to fully professionalize and gain sufficient national goodwill and support, so crucial for its continuity, it will have to unlearn a great deal of the anti-democracy lessons imparted by Mr Museveni and his strongman style of politics. That won’t be easy considering that most of the generals, supposed to re-orient and sanitise the UPDF are the same officers who have been harassing and brutalising political opposition members on behalf of president Museveni.
Their predicament is further complicated by the fact that their participation in Museveni’s machinations is itself done in self-interest since through maintaining Museveni’s dictatorship they perpetuate their own impunity.
There are decidedly less explored undercurrents that will nevertheless prove crucial in the future of UPDF. It has been politically incorrect for the media in Uganda to debate the longstanding accusations of tribal marginalisation in the military. Lately though, these incendiary accusations have been amplified anew by disaffected elements within the NRM. And official denials have appeared to inflame it further by inviting closer scrutiny of the tribal composition of the army. Mr Museveni’s perennial justification for the Bahima’s predominance in the army has been that they initially formed the nucleus of the NRA but after 22 years of little or no change, many are now dismissing this argument as a smokescreen for his sectarianism.
The pandemic of grand corruption in the army, one of Mr Museveni’s most hideous legacies will for long retard the growth of UPDF and there’s expected little change when he leaves power. The embezzlement of vast sums of money in payments of phantom troops, procurement of arms and even diversion of salaries for real soldiers have resulted in the perpetuation of critical capacity limitations. The consequences of this corruption have been colossally tragic as in the army’s failure to end the war in northern Uganda.
Few expect this state of affairs to change in a post-Museveni Uganda. But the cost of failure to end army corruption will probably be greater than what the nation has paid so far.
It could continue weakening the military up to a point where it’s vulnerable to upheaval and in a post-Museveni Uganda that point could come closer far faster than many can imagine.
Kampala--From its founding in 1981, through the guerrilla battles to the seizure of power in ’86, transformation into a national army and then on to the current multiparty politics, the UPDF (formerly, NRA) has been run as a de facto personal army of President Yoweri Museveni.
Mr Museveni’s influence within the UPDF is so pervasive and overweening—or so he has made people believe—that most Ugandans have long understood it as nearly impossible for this institution to stand without him. And so there is a considerable measure of wonder and apprehension about the sort and extent of change, if any, that will sweep through the UPDF in a post-Museveni Uganda.
While it is true that the army has long shed some of its historical ties to Mr. Museveni and assumed a national character and visage, it still maintains lots of cultish loyalty and reverence for its founder and a great deal of the army command structures and functioning appear to spin around his personal authority that its unclear how that institution’s integrity will continue when its supposed centre of gravity (Mr Museveni) erodes.
In Ex Army Commander, Major Gen Mugisha Muntu’s prognosis, the UPDF can survive Mr Museveni’s political demise and grow even stronger but that that will depend on the evolving character of the force and factors influencing its internal growth and transformation.
There’s a growing cadreship of elite officers (highly educated, trained and modernist in outlook), Muntu observed, that is increasingly gravitating toward independent thinking and action and that if the future of UPDF is shaped by these officers then worries of an institutional breakdown after Museveni would be wanton. “Yes, they’re all these educated and inspiring officers in our military that are upcoming,” he said. “I think they represent the hope and continuity of our army.”
Encouragingly, too, the elongated stability of Uganda’s politics and the growing strength of some of the country’s democratic institutions and the spread of civil liberties—parliament, opposition parties, the media, civil society—is also cited by analysts to be quietly shaping the mindsets and general character of these officers. Increasingly a growing section within the military leadership, according to a source in the intelligence community, is inevitably realising that the army has little choice but to defend these young institutions and this epiphany will ultimately determine how the military behaves upon the exit of the founding Commander-in-Chief.
Be that as it may, plenty of hints here and there do not seem to point to a reassuring future. Another source within Mr. Museveni’s intelligence circle lamented the president’s persistent use of the army in his personal political manoeuvres, noting that the practise has now become so entrenched that it will take a long time to reverse.
In all the elections Uganda has had for instance under Mr Museveni—1996, 2001, 2006—the army has inserted itself (or has been inserted) right at the centre, with several senior raking officers actively conducting covert campaigns for President Museveni. The current coordinator of Intelligence Services, Mr David Tinyefuza and Maj. Gen Elly Tumwine overtly campaigned for President Museveni in 2001 and issued dreadful threats against his key opponent Col. Dr Kiiza Besigye. The same was reprised in 2006 elections.
For the UPDF to fully professionalize and gain sufficient national goodwill and support, so crucial for its continuity, it will have to unlearn a great deal of the anti-democracy lessons imparted by Mr Museveni and his strongman style of politics. That won’t be easy considering that most of the generals, supposed to re-orient and sanitise the UPDF are the same officers who have been harassing and brutalising political opposition members on behalf of president Museveni.
Their predicament is further complicated by the fact that their participation in Museveni’s machinations is itself done in self-interest since through maintaining Museveni’s dictatorship they perpetuate their own impunity.
There are decidedly less explored undercurrents that will nevertheless prove crucial in the future of UPDF. It has been politically incorrect for the media in Uganda to debate the longstanding accusations of tribal marginalisation in the military. Lately though, these incendiary accusations have been amplified anew by disaffected elements within the NRM. And official denials have appeared to inflame it further by inviting closer scrutiny of the tribal composition of the army. Mr Museveni’s perennial justification for the Bahima’s predominance in the army has been that they initially formed the nucleus of the NRA but after 22 years of little or no change, many are now dismissing this argument as a smokescreen for his sectarianism.
The pandemic of grand corruption in the army, one of Mr Museveni’s most hideous legacies will for long retard the growth of UPDF and there’s expected little change when he leaves power. The embezzlement of vast sums of money in payments of phantom troops, procurement of arms and even diversion of salaries for real soldiers have resulted in the perpetuation of critical capacity limitations. The consequences of this corruption have been colossally tragic as in the army’s failure to end the war in northern Uganda.
Few expect this state of affairs to change in a post-Museveni Uganda. But the cost of failure to end army corruption will probably be greater than what the nation has paid so far.
It could continue weakening the military up to a point where it’s vulnerable to upheaval and in a post-Museveni Uganda that point could come closer far faster than many can imagine.
Thursday, February 21, 2008
Post-Museveni Parliament: A Legacy of the Power of Patronage
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
In the 22 years that Mr. Yoweri Museveni has led Uganda, his has been largely an imperial presidency with his hand literally in every pie. Just about every important state institution has long gotten used to his frequent personal intervention which has come to influence the functioning (or malfunctioning) of these institutions. They have more or less been modelled in his image and there’s not much clarity and understanding on how these institutions might operate in case the person, on whom their very existence has revolved, exits power. In a new eight-part series I delve into some of the key institutions and government policies and show how they will change or not change in a Post-Museveni Uganda.
The First which runs today tackles Parliament.
**********
KAMPALA--For all the rhetorical bluster and bumble that occasionally issues from the “dissident” sections of members of parliament, the legislature under president Museveni’s 22-year administration, has largely been conformist and pliant all through.
Under the quaint individual-merit Movement system starting with the 6th Parliament in1996, there prevailed a presumption that the legislators had unencumbered latitude to pursue independent thinking and perform their work free from the corrupting influence of the executive. However, as Museveni’s regime entrenched itself in power and sought tighter control of all state institutions, the legislature was slowly pulled and enmeshed in the web of executive manoeuvres, which soon handed president Museveni powerful levers with which he controlled parliamentarians, their debates and their outcomes.
That relationship has been sustained by a convenient trade-off between the MPs (majority of them) who have allowed their minds to be stewarded by Museveni’s whims in return for a copious flow of endless patronage in form of money, plum appointments and, for some, guarantee of impunity. This symbiosis between Museveni and a large section of parliamentarians has produced one of the most twisted and duplicitous democracies in the region, with the parliament , the most paramount check on the executive, appearing robust and effective while it is in fact hopelessly hamstrung, busying itself with rubberstamping the president’s wild wishes and fantasies.
The climax to this strange pattern of behaviour was the brazen bribing of MPs in late 2005 to acquiesce in Museveni’s “life-presidency” ambition by deleting the two-term cap on incumbency in the constitution.
If there’s any noticeable legacy thus—regarding the respect and fostering of the role of parliament as a pillar of a strong and well governed state—that President Museveni’s administration will bequeath to the successive leader when he eventually quits power, it will be one of venality and political sleaze, according to Prof. Fredrick Ssempebwa. What Museveni has demonstrated, according to analysts, is how a leader can masterfully use money and privilege to sedate stubborn but economically vulnerable House members and this evolving political culture will characterise parliament for some time in future.
“What has been most outstanding in president Museveni’s relationship with Parliament is his broad use of manipulation and patronage to steer the latter to his political ends,” Ssempebwa said.
To be sure, just about every leader in the world uses patronage to extract loyalty and support for himself. But, according to observers, Mr Museveni’s form of patronage is highly personalised, inimical to development and politically polarising. Most other leaders spread their patronage amongst masses, for instance spending money on public works for which they turn around and claim political capital. “Obote for instance built the 22 hospitals which were in part used to re-energise his support across the areas where those hospitals were located,” commented one senior politician confidentially.
“So over and above his political goals, those hospitals served to improve health care for the masses. This is different Museveni type of patronage where he directly hands out cash to his loyalist MPs.”
Future leaders, according to Ssempebwa’s prognosis, have learned from Museveni how best to extend their overreaching power to parliament and prevent opposition elements from gaining wide support and presenting formidable obstacles to executive requests. There’s one particular technique that Museveni has long adeptly exploited to manoeuvre his way around parliamentary oversight—hosting and feting MPs at State House and his country home of Rwakitura.
It is now almost standard practise: a bill is facing mounting opposition in parliament; some Movement legislators are voicing discontent, a budget request is facing rejection by a House committee, a financial scandal is swirling in the House; the President will quickly invite respective MPs for “tea” at Nakasero or Rwakitura at the end of which MPs are seen to soften their stance on the matter in question or even switching positions altogether.
When Museveni desired a more luxurious (and costlier) presidential jet (G555), in December last year for instance he invited members on the Presidential and Foreign Affairs Committee to Nakasero and cajoled them into succumbing to his unpopular request even as it looked certain to provoke a groundswell of anger.
Still, Museveni prevailed at the end of the day in part because the parliamentary committee supposed to be the people’s first line of defence against executive excesses had yielded perhaps in the face of Museveni’s intimidating gaze at Naksero.
Ex legislator, Mr Nobert Mao summed up Mr Museveni’s manipulation of MPs, “he’s managing a multiparty parliament using movement software.” In a post Museveni Uganda he forecast a brutal backlash against legislators who displayed fierce loyalty to Museveni because, he said, future leaders will not want to be encumbered by the baggage of NRM’s past wrongs. “There will be a purge of loyalists and I think once Museveni departs, Uganda’s parliament won’t be dominated by the NRM,” he said.
Ultimately, the integrity of parliament which has vastly eroded under Museveni’s Movement and NRM administrations will depend on the personality of whichever leader succeeds the incumbent.
What is less in doubt though is that if that leader lifts a page from Museveni’s parliamentary playbook, there’s plenty that should worry Ugandans in trusting their legislators to guard their interests against executive sleaze and corruption.
In the 22 years that Mr. Yoweri Museveni has led Uganda, his has been largely an imperial presidency with his hand literally in every pie. Just about every important state institution has long gotten used to his frequent personal intervention which has come to influence the functioning (or malfunctioning) of these institutions. They have more or less been modelled in his image and there’s not much clarity and understanding on how these institutions might operate in case the person, on whom their very existence has revolved, exits power. In a new eight-part series I delve into some of the key institutions and government policies and show how they will change or not change in a Post-Museveni Uganda.
The First which runs today tackles Parliament.
**********
KAMPALA--For all the rhetorical bluster and bumble that occasionally issues from the “dissident” sections of members of parliament, the legislature under president Museveni’s 22-year administration, has largely been conformist and pliant all through.
Under the quaint individual-merit Movement system starting with the 6th Parliament in1996, there prevailed a presumption that the legislators had unencumbered latitude to pursue independent thinking and perform their work free from the corrupting influence of the executive. However, as Museveni’s regime entrenched itself in power and sought tighter control of all state institutions, the legislature was slowly pulled and enmeshed in the web of executive manoeuvres, which soon handed president Museveni powerful levers with which he controlled parliamentarians, their debates and their outcomes.
That relationship has been sustained by a convenient trade-off between the MPs (majority of them) who have allowed their minds to be stewarded by Museveni’s whims in return for a copious flow of endless patronage in form of money, plum appointments and, for some, guarantee of impunity. This symbiosis between Museveni and a large section of parliamentarians has produced one of the most twisted and duplicitous democracies in the region, with the parliament , the most paramount check on the executive, appearing robust and effective while it is in fact hopelessly hamstrung, busying itself with rubberstamping the president’s wild wishes and fantasies.
The climax to this strange pattern of behaviour was the brazen bribing of MPs in late 2005 to acquiesce in Museveni’s “life-presidency” ambition by deleting the two-term cap on incumbency in the constitution.
If there’s any noticeable legacy thus—regarding the respect and fostering of the role of parliament as a pillar of a strong and well governed state—that President Museveni’s administration will bequeath to the successive leader when he eventually quits power, it will be one of venality and political sleaze, according to Prof. Fredrick Ssempebwa. What Museveni has demonstrated, according to analysts, is how a leader can masterfully use money and privilege to sedate stubborn but economically vulnerable House members and this evolving political culture will characterise parliament for some time in future.
“What has been most outstanding in president Museveni’s relationship with Parliament is his broad use of manipulation and patronage to steer the latter to his political ends,” Ssempebwa said.
To be sure, just about every leader in the world uses patronage to extract loyalty and support for himself. But, according to observers, Mr Museveni’s form of patronage is highly personalised, inimical to development and politically polarising. Most other leaders spread their patronage amongst masses, for instance spending money on public works for which they turn around and claim political capital. “Obote for instance built the 22 hospitals which were in part used to re-energise his support across the areas where those hospitals were located,” commented one senior politician confidentially.
“So over and above his political goals, those hospitals served to improve health care for the masses. This is different Museveni type of patronage where he directly hands out cash to his loyalist MPs.”
Future leaders, according to Ssempebwa’s prognosis, have learned from Museveni how best to extend their overreaching power to parliament and prevent opposition elements from gaining wide support and presenting formidable obstacles to executive requests. There’s one particular technique that Museveni has long adeptly exploited to manoeuvre his way around parliamentary oversight—hosting and feting MPs at State House and his country home of Rwakitura.
It is now almost standard practise: a bill is facing mounting opposition in parliament; some Movement legislators are voicing discontent, a budget request is facing rejection by a House committee, a financial scandal is swirling in the House; the President will quickly invite respective MPs for “tea” at Nakasero or Rwakitura at the end of which MPs are seen to soften their stance on the matter in question or even switching positions altogether.
When Museveni desired a more luxurious (and costlier) presidential jet (G555), in December last year for instance he invited members on the Presidential and Foreign Affairs Committee to Nakasero and cajoled them into succumbing to his unpopular request even as it looked certain to provoke a groundswell of anger.
Still, Museveni prevailed at the end of the day in part because the parliamentary committee supposed to be the people’s first line of defence against executive excesses had yielded perhaps in the face of Museveni’s intimidating gaze at Naksero.
Ex legislator, Mr Nobert Mao summed up Mr Museveni’s manipulation of MPs, “he’s managing a multiparty parliament using movement software.” In a post Museveni Uganda he forecast a brutal backlash against legislators who displayed fierce loyalty to Museveni because, he said, future leaders will not want to be encumbered by the baggage of NRM’s past wrongs. “There will be a purge of loyalists and I think once Museveni departs, Uganda’s parliament won’t be dominated by the NRM,” he said.
Ultimately, the integrity of parliament which has vastly eroded under Museveni’s Movement and NRM administrations will depend on the personality of whichever leader succeeds the incumbent.
What is less in doubt though is that if that leader lifts a page from Museveni’s parliamentary playbook, there’s plenty that should worry Ugandans in trusting their legislators to guard their interests against executive sleaze and corruption.
Epidemics Return Uganda to its Truer Image
ELIAS BRYABAREMA
KAMPALA--When Uganda hosted the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, Chogm, the country was hardly mentioned in most of the American press, arguably the most influential section of the Western media.
The British media though did offer considerable coverage casting Uganda, momentarily, in global news pages, for better or worse. According to the government, the foremost justification for the colossal sums of money spent on organising Chogm2007 was because the event would present the country with something of once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to showcase its supposed bountiful potential to the world.
As to whether that happened during the weeklong Chogm meetings (November 19th-25th) remains unclear.
But if Chogm did indeed market brand Uganda to the world, then President Museveni and his NRM government might already be banging their heads on the walls asking why a cruel misfortune had to strike so soon, instantly wiping out all the gloss newly put on the nation’s face.
Just in a flash, by an act of Nature, Uganda has been lunged back to its standard sub-Saharan African default image: disease, pain and suffering. As November ebbed and sunk on the horizon, Uganda started to hit global headlines as the hemorrhagic fever Ebola tightened its horrific grip on the nation, four days after the end of Chogm2007.
On December 5th that catastrophe was added on weight with Daily Monitor reporting an additional quadruple outbreak of bubonic plague which struck West Nile, Cholera in Hoima and Yellow Fever in Kitgum.
Since then, nearly all the news churned out of Uganda by the global newswires (AFP, Reuters, Associated Press, Bloomberg, Xinhua etc) has been on the Ebola epidemic and little else somehow cementing the traditional world perception of Uganda as just about that of any other sub-Saharan African backwater: nations still susceptible to outbreaks of diseases even as simple as Cholera.
The devastating impact of the current Ebola strike on Uganda’s image is boldly noticeable in the American press which in the first place never bothered to report anything substantially positive about the country’s hosting of Chogm. New York Times reported, “Ebola Kills 19 Ugandans,” on 4th December. Similar stories run in several others major US newspapers.
This is particularly distressing considering that president Museveni has made countless trips to the US to court investors there, only for them to be inundated with the terrifying news of health epidemics trumpeted in their press.
Museveni’s Media Advisor, Mr. John Nagenda ridiculed any derivation of contrasts between Chogm and the Ebola epidemic. “It’s the mindless that can start drawing any links between Ebola and Chogm. This is a natural epidemic that can hit any country.” he said yesterday.
The government, he said, was scrambling to marshal resources and respond adequately so that the epidemics can be blunted as quickly as possible. He was empathic in dismissing the notion that any image mileage that Uganda could have wrung out of successful (some say) hosting of Chogm has already been eroded by the epidemic.
Nagenda could be right that epidemics are natural and that it would possibly be sadistic to start throwing mean arguments around them as cynics are wont to do (are already doing!). But again, as is well known, health catastrophes like cholera are now only a preserve of countries that are trapped in primordial living conditions like those in parts of Uganda and most of sub-Saharan Africa. And even Ebola, which would seem to have no connection with the level of economic development: all its past eruptions have been confined to sub-Saharan Africa; Sudan, Uganda, D. R. Congo and Angola—countries that share just about the same living conditions.
At the end Chogm Museveni, newly energised and soaring from the Chogm success addressed journalists delighting in the success of Chogm and the new global power it had rendered Uganda’s “Gifted by Nature” brand.
Now, the same Nature has, unsympathetic to Museveni, turned malevolent and put everything asunder and dragged the country back to its melancholic existence.
KAMPALA--When Uganda hosted the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, Chogm, the country was hardly mentioned in most of the American press, arguably the most influential section of the Western media.
The British media though did offer considerable coverage casting Uganda, momentarily, in global news pages, for better or worse. According to the government, the foremost justification for the colossal sums of money spent on organising Chogm2007 was because the event would present the country with something of once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to showcase its supposed bountiful potential to the world.
As to whether that happened during the weeklong Chogm meetings (November 19th-25th) remains unclear.
But if Chogm did indeed market brand Uganda to the world, then President Museveni and his NRM government might already be banging their heads on the walls asking why a cruel misfortune had to strike so soon, instantly wiping out all the gloss newly put on the nation’s face.
Just in a flash, by an act of Nature, Uganda has been lunged back to its standard sub-Saharan African default image: disease, pain and suffering. As November ebbed and sunk on the horizon, Uganda started to hit global headlines as the hemorrhagic fever Ebola tightened its horrific grip on the nation, four days after the end of Chogm2007.
On December 5th that catastrophe was added on weight with Daily Monitor reporting an additional quadruple outbreak of bubonic plague which struck West Nile, Cholera in Hoima and Yellow Fever in Kitgum.
Since then, nearly all the news churned out of Uganda by the global newswires (AFP, Reuters, Associated Press, Bloomberg, Xinhua etc) has been on the Ebola epidemic and little else somehow cementing the traditional world perception of Uganda as just about that of any other sub-Saharan African backwater: nations still susceptible to outbreaks of diseases even as simple as Cholera.
The devastating impact of the current Ebola strike on Uganda’s image is boldly noticeable in the American press which in the first place never bothered to report anything substantially positive about the country’s hosting of Chogm. New York Times reported, “Ebola Kills 19 Ugandans,” on 4th December. Similar stories run in several others major US newspapers.
This is particularly distressing considering that president Museveni has made countless trips to the US to court investors there, only for them to be inundated with the terrifying news of health epidemics trumpeted in their press.
Museveni’s Media Advisor, Mr. John Nagenda ridiculed any derivation of contrasts between Chogm and the Ebola epidemic. “It’s the mindless that can start drawing any links between Ebola and Chogm. This is a natural epidemic that can hit any country.” he said yesterday.
The government, he said, was scrambling to marshal resources and respond adequately so that the epidemics can be blunted as quickly as possible. He was empathic in dismissing the notion that any image mileage that Uganda could have wrung out of successful (some say) hosting of Chogm has already been eroded by the epidemic.
Nagenda could be right that epidemics are natural and that it would possibly be sadistic to start throwing mean arguments around them as cynics are wont to do (are already doing!). But again, as is well known, health catastrophes like cholera are now only a preserve of countries that are trapped in primordial living conditions like those in parts of Uganda and most of sub-Saharan Africa. And even Ebola, which would seem to have no connection with the level of economic development: all its past eruptions have been confined to sub-Saharan Africa; Sudan, Uganda, D. R. Congo and Angola—countries that share just about the same living conditions.
At the end Chogm Museveni, newly energised and soaring from the Chogm success addressed journalists delighting in the success of Chogm and the new global power it had rendered Uganda’s “Gifted by Nature” brand.
Now, the same Nature has, unsympathetic to Museveni, turned malevolent and put everything asunder and dragged the country back to its melancholic existence.
Monday, January 28, 2008
A successor from the palace. But who might that be?
On January 2, 2007 the Red Pepper reported that intelligence personnel were stuck with a report that showed that President Yoweri Museveni's wife, Janet Kataha Museveni intends to contest in the 2011 presidential elections.
Although that story appeared extra-ordinarily remarkable - for better or worse - it was never picked up by pundits in Kampala's energetic debate circuit and it soon slipped under the media radar and then off to the pages of history.
Noteworthy though was that, that report was never refuted by State House.
A few attuned commentators noted it and, in a review of the major news of the year, Daily Monitor writer Mr Timothy Kalyegira cited it as one of the key political news of 2007.
For the first time, a small window was opened for the public into the scale of the political ambitions of the second most powerful member of State House.
And even beyond that it also helped signal to Ugandans the sort of political fault-lines and the jockeying that could form in Uganda's innermost sanctum of power in case President Museveni ever becomes incapacitated in office or resigns.
Insiders in State House told Daily Monitor that President Museveni does not espouse Janet's involvement in politics.
When she announced, late in 2005, that she would compete for the Ruhama County MP seat, Mr Museveni was later quoted by the media as saying that he had tried to discourage his wife from engaging in elective politics.
When someone chooses to set aside the revered status of 'Mother of the Nation' and enter the muddy fields of elective and characteristically partisan politics, it cannot be for a small reason.
Then she explained that in standing, she was obeying a command from God. After gaining the experience of competitive constituency politics for five years, what is to stop God from commanding her to seek the bigger constituency called Uganda?
But since Museveni did not want her in politics, it can be deduced that he has other ideas in his head regarding which members of his circle should succeed him in case his health were to fail him.
In June 2006, while speaking at the launch of Vumilia, an association of soldiers' widows and orphans at Sheraton Hotel, Museveni dropped an eye-popping hint - First Son, Maj. Muhoozi Keinerugaba, he suggested, should start from where he finishes.
Mr Museveni was quoted by Daily Monitor as saying in Luganda, "Omwana yagenda okutwala mu maso omulimo gwa kitawe. Mutabani wange namuyita Muhoozi. Enkya, Muhoozi yagenda okuwolera eggwanga," meaning he desired Maj.Muhoozi to carry on his job.
According to the story Mr Museveni clearly signalled he had high expectations for his son and also described Gen. Salim Saleh as one of those NRM cadres that are graduating into "more challenging roles." Which job does Museveni want Maj. Muhoozi to carry on? Cattle ranching at Kisozi and Rwakitura?
If this is what he is being prepared for, veterinary studies do not feature prominently on the various curricular he has been pursuing at different academies abroad over the past decade. And the only employment he has held in between was not in the Ministries of Agriculture, but that of Defence?
Maj. Muhoozi attended the world-famous military academy, Sandhurst of UK where he graduated in May 2001 and was later curiously promoted by Libyan leader Col. Muammar Ghadaffi from Lieutenant to Major.
The UPDF sucked the air out of the controversy by describing the new rank as a "loan" for which Muhoozi had to train and work to earn.
In the likelihood that Mr Museveni becomes incapacitated while in office, a scenario whose possibility we've explained in earlier parts of this series, many observes think some system insiders would pick on Maj. Muhoozi, who will in any case have climbed higher in army leadership to take over the presidency.
But if Mr Museveni shares such "presidential plans" for his son, then he might face a wrenching quandary in reconciling them with a scenario if the First Lady Janet equally got orders from above (God) to pursue higher political ambitions as were reported by the Red Pepper.
Patriotism
And that's before Gen. Saleh, a man whom President Museveni has historically praised as a brave and patriotic fighter and "a clean man" despite many controversial issues where he has been cited as a central figure, like the botched underground sale of Uganda Commercial Bank and the junk chopper deal.
Gen. Saleh, according to one State House source, was ats one time ranking high on President Museveni's list of possible successors, alongside Brig. Henry Tumukunde. Then, according to this source, Gen. Saleh ruined his record with "alcohol and an obsession with money" while Brig. Tumukunde later allied himself with the 'wrong forces'.
Still, Gen. Saleh could be persuaded by many due to his strong following within the army and appeal to the ordinary people across the country, in the incident of a power vacuum, to 'hold the fort' and keep the country stable, adding a third dimension to the potential power contenders at State House.
But would the feelings of Ugandans over a member of the first family "inheriting" power from Museveni matter and can they prevent it if they don't like the idea?
There are some basic facts that point us to what is possible and what is less possible. Sources indicate for instance that Maj. Muhoozi has considerable control of PGB, which is widely understood to be the paramount centre of power within the army.
It would be possible for him, if he wanted, to parlay this strategic control and rally the army behind him. However, that is not a guarantee that such a transition would be that smooth.
Some members in senior army leadership might balk at the father-son, husband-wife or brother-brother succession and possibly attempt to foil it, sparking a fight within the military.
"There will likely be a lot of infighting within the palace," remarked Prof. Fredrick Sepebwa. "A coup is still possible."
While Ugandans have largely shown a timid reluctance to engage usurpers of power, they have lately cultivated a stomach for determined confrontation with police, a trend visible since November 2005 when Dr Kiiza Besigye was arrested.
This toughening militancy within the population could be easily exploited by opposition politicians to successfully thwart any extra-constitutional father-son or husband-wife succession.
Of course Mr Museveni's relatives are free to pursue constitutional means to succeed him.
Across the spectrum of Ugandan's political views, there's a general consensus that there's basically nothing wrong with Janet Museveni, Keinerugaba Muhoozi or any of Mr Museveni's close relatives succeeding him as long he/she does so in conformity with the laws of the land.
"Members of the first family, like any other Ugandan, are at liberty to play their rightful role in society," senior politician and Internal Affairs Minister Ruhakana Rugunda said about a possible succession from within the president's household.
However should any of these close relatives fall short on charisma and experience in the skilful and patient maneuvers of statecraft, it's unlikely that they would resist the temptation of using coercive force (the military) to pursue their ambitions.
And if Mr Museveni ever gets incapacitated in office, all forces with access to the military may try to usurp power against resistance from the population, and this could spark one of the most explosive political developments whose consequences are hard to ponder.
Although that story appeared extra-ordinarily remarkable - for better or worse - it was never picked up by pundits in Kampala's energetic debate circuit and it soon slipped under the media radar and then off to the pages of history.
Noteworthy though was that, that report was never refuted by State House.
A few attuned commentators noted it and, in a review of the major news of the year, Daily Monitor writer Mr Timothy Kalyegira cited it as one of the key political news of 2007.
For the first time, a small window was opened for the public into the scale of the political ambitions of the second most powerful member of State House.
And even beyond that it also helped signal to Ugandans the sort of political fault-lines and the jockeying that could form in Uganda's innermost sanctum of power in case President Museveni ever becomes incapacitated in office or resigns.
Insiders in State House told Daily Monitor that President Museveni does not espouse Janet's involvement in politics.
When she announced, late in 2005, that she would compete for the Ruhama County MP seat, Mr Museveni was later quoted by the media as saying that he had tried to discourage his wife from engaging in elective politics.
When someone chooses to set aside the revered status of 'Mother of the Nation' and enter the muddy fields of elective and characteristically partisan politics, it cannot be for a small reason.
Then she explained that in standing, she was obeying a command from God. After gaining the experience of competitive constituency politics for five years, what is to stop God from commanding her to seek the bigger constituency called Uganda?
But since Museveni did not want her in politics, it can be deduced that he has other ideas in his head regarding which members of his circle should succeed him in case his health were to fail him.
In June 2006, while speaking at the launch of Vumilia, an association of soldiers' widows and orphans at Sheraton Hotel, Museveni dropped an eye-popping hint - First Son, Maj. Muhoozi Keinerugaba, he suggested, should start from where he finishes.
Mr Museveni was quoted by Daily Monitor as saying in Luganda, "Omwana yagenda okutwala mu maso omulimo gwa kitawe. Mutabani wange namuyita Muhoozi. Enkya, Muhoozi yagenda okuwolera eggwanga," meaning he desired Maj.Muhoozi to carry on his job.
According to the story Mr Museveni clearly signalled he had high expectations for his son and also described Gen. Salim Saleh as one of those NRM cadres that are graduating into "more challenging roles." Which job does Museveni want Maj. Muhoozi to carry on? Cattle ranching at Kisozi and Rwakitura?
If this is what he is being prepared for, veterinary studies do not feature prominently on the various curricular he has been pursuing at different academies abroad over the past decade. And the only employment he has held in between was not in the Ministries of Agriculture, but that of Defence?
Maj. Muhoozi attended the world-famous military academy, Sandhurst of UK where he graduated in May 2001 and was later curiously promoted by Libyan leader Col. Muammar Ghadaffi from Lieutenant to Major.
The UPDF sucked the air out of the controversy by describing the new rank as a "loan" for which Muhoozi had to train and work to earn.
In the likelihood that Mr Museveni becomes incapacitated while in office, a scenario whose possibility we've explained in earlier parts of this series, many observes think some system insiders would pick on Maj. Muhoozi, who will in any case have climbed higher in army leadership to take over the presidency.
But if Mr Museveni shares such "presidential plans" for his son, then he might face a wrenching quandary in reconciling them with a scenario if the First Lady Janet equally got orders from above (God) to pursue higher political ambitions as were reported by the Red Pepper.
Patriotism
And that's before Gen. Saleh, a man whom President Museveni has historically praised as a brave and patriotic fighter and "a clean man" despite many controversial issues where he has been cited as a central figure, like the botched underground sale of Uganda Commercial Bank and the junk chopper deal.
Gen. Saleh, according to one State House source, was ats one time ranking high on President Museveni's list of possible successors, alongside Brig. Henry Tumukunde. Then, according to this source, Gen. Saleh ruined his record with "alcohol and an obsession with money" while Brig. Tumukunde later allied himself with the 'wrong forces'.
Still, Gen. Saleh could be persuaded by many due to his strong following within the army and appeal to the ordinary people across the country, in the incident of a power vacuum, to 'hold the fort' and keep the country stable, adding a third dimension to the potential power contenders at State House.
But would the feelings of Ugandans over a member of the first family "inheriting" power from Museveni matter and can they prevent it if they don't like the idea?
There are some basic facts that point us to what is possible and what is less possible. Sources indicate for instance that Maj. Muhoozi has considerable control of PGB, which is widely understood to be the paramount centre of power within the army.
It would be possible for him, if he wanted, to parlay this strategic control and rally the army behind him. However, that is not a guarantee that such a transition would be that smooth.
Some members in senior army leadership might balk at the father-son, husband-wife or brother-brother succession and possibly attempt to foil it, sparking a fight within the military.
"There will likely be a lot of infighting within the palace," remarked Prof. Fredrick Sepebwa. "A coup is still possible."
While Ugandans have largely shown a timid reluctance to engage usurpers of power, they have lately cultivated a stomach for determined confrontation with police, a trend visible since November 2005 when Dr Kiiza Besigye was arrested.
This toughening militancy within the population could be easily exploited by opposition politicians to successfully thwart any extra-constitutional father-son or husband-wife succession.
Of course Mr Museveni's relatives are free to pursue constitutional means to succeed him.
Across the spectrum of Ugandan's political views, there's a general consensus that there's basically nothing wrong with Janet Museveni, Keinerugaba Muhoozi or any of Mr Museveni's close relatives succeeding him as long he/she does so in conformity with the laws of the land.
"Members of the first family, like any other Ugandan, are at liberty to play their rightful role in society," senior politician and Internal Affairs Minister Ruhakana Rugunda said about a possible succession from within the president's household.
However should any of these close relatives fall short on charisma and experience in the skilful and patient maneuvers of statecraft, it's unlikely that they would resist the temptation of using coercive force (the military) to pursue their ambitions.
And if Mr Museveni ever gets incapacitated in office, all forces with access to the military may try to usurp power against resistance from the population, and this could spark one of the most explosive political developments whose consequences are hard to ponder.
Friday, December 21, 2007
Museveni Succession: Can army allow VP to take over?
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
KAMPALA
On a September 5th 2007 visit to Dwaniro, Kiboga District in central Uganda which hosted one of the rearguard bases for his vicious National Resistance Army, NRA insurgency against the UPC government (1981-85), President Yoweri Museveni let slip past his mouth a chilling revelation.
"If you had not elected us in 1996 and had not given us the mandate, we would have gone back to the bush to fight," Mr Museveni was quoted by national media on September 7 as telling the gathered peasants.
Perhaps it was tactical that Mr Museveni had chosen a rural setting, and an audience that could hardly perceive the extraordinary import of his statements to deliver what might be the most telling clue to the mindset and character of the NRA and its offspring, the UDPF.
Even if they had lost the election, Mr Museveni declared, they (him and his soldiers, the NRA) could never have allowed the "killers" who he said had backed DP's Paul Kawanga Ssemogerere, to come to power.
The inference from Mr Museveni's revelation was that the army and its Commander-in-Chief were unwilling to cede power regardless of Ugandans' choice. That was only a year after Uganda had gotten a new Constitution with free and fair elections as one of its sacrosanct principles.
"In simple English: Mr Museveni would have overthrown the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda," Dr Muniini Mulera a regular commentator on Uganda's politics said.
And this is the possibility we seek to explore in the second part of our series which delves into whether the UPDF would ever allow a civilian to assume power in case the incumbent slipped into incapacitation.
In the formal and automated process of national governance, succession in such a scenario is pretty straightforward and clear: the Vice President (currently Prof. Gilbert Bukenya) would assume office. But in the cold and brutal realities of Ugandan politics, succession never seems to follow a standard path, as is much of Sub-Saharan Africa.
And so, it's never a given as our Constitution suggests that power would automatically flow where it's supposed to if the presidency suddenly falls vacant. It all really hinges on how the army, the single force that has historically directed the course of power in independent Uganda, will act or not act.
"Ours is to respect the rule of law," insisted UPDF spokesperson, Maj. Felix Kulayigye in an interview on December 11. "Subject to the Constitution, we'll submit to whoever is in power as long as he's there legally."
The genteel and thoughtful Internal Affairs Minister, Dr Ruhakana Rugunda, too sees any suggestion of a possible UPDF interference in the succession process as mere conjecture.
But his optimism derives from a basic assumption. "The question of succession is a small point," he told Daily Monitor on December 12. "Because it has been well sorted out by the Constitution."
Still, beyond the assertions of Maj. Kulayigye and Dr Rugunda, there is a lot for Ugandans to fret about. The history of UPDF is not a history of virtue and patriotism.
Threats
In the heat of the 2001 presidential election campaigns, the current Coordinator of Intelligence Agencies in Uganda, Gen. David Tinyefuza, infamously declared that he would not submit to Dr Kiiza Besigye if the latter won the presidency.
And the former Director General of the Internal Security Organisation, Brig. Henry Tumukunde, reminded voters that whatever they did, Mr Museveni would still rule because they still had their guns.
Although such statements from serving (and senior) army officers would appear to carry a treasonable intent, there was never so much as a verbal reprimand from the army leadership then: corroborating what Mr Museveni implied later in Dwaniro - only the will of the army would really determine who rules Uganda.
Obviously, Gen. Tinyefuza's and Brig. Tumukunde's utterances are starkly incongruous with Maj. Kulayigye and Dr Rugunda's assertions of UPDF being a professional army, ready to submit to whichever Commander-in-Chief Ugandans (the people) may chose. Another incident, too, does undermine the glowing portrayals of UPDF.
On February 15, 2006, Lt. Ramathan Magara shot into a crowd of Dr Kiiza Besigye supporters at Bulange, Mengo, killing two people and permanently maiming a third. That tragedy, by a soldier during multiparty election campaigns, drew nationwide outrage and became a timeless stain on the UPDF.
But to the consternation of many, Lt. Magara was never court-martialled. The army instead disowned him and he was later charged in a civilian court and promptly granted bail, virtually leaving him a free man.
Lt. Magala killings
That a soldier could orchestrate such gruesome violence against an opponent of Mr Museveni, and he's even defended by elements in government (an RDC, Mr Fred Bamwine did) again underlines that faceless but decisive role of the army in determining Uganda's president.
True, Maj. Kulaigye's explanation initially sounds firm. "He's a civilian. He was retired from the army and so we couldn't try him."
But then it is Mr Museveni who invented a solution for civilians that use instruments that are a preserve of the army: court-martial. Lt. Magara used an AK 47 to murder the civilians, a weapon never licensed for civilian defence and only used by the security forces.
That is the government's justification to subject whoever handles an AK47 in Uganda to military law. How stupefying then that a 'retired' soldier could take up an AK 47, unleash a bloodbath and be spared a court-martial? Instead, since his release, Lt. Magara has claimed to be a representative of the President at one function.
Also telling is the army's feeling of entitlement to a major political role in Uganda. Even after constitutional amendments to suit the multiparty system, the army, about 50,000 strong, still maintains 10 seats in Parliament, even though all 10 are supposed to have only one view.
Clearly, the army sees itself as far more important than the rest of the population for at their ratio of parliamentary representation of 1:5000, Uganda's Parliament would have 6,000 MPs for a population of 30 million, if the civilian citizens were deemed to be equal to the soldiers in importance.
But to the leader of the Opposition, Prof Morris Ogenga Latigo, fears of UPDF hijacking power in case their current Commander-in-Chief got incapacitated in office are naïve. Coup d'états, he said on December 12, are anachronistic. "Time when soldiers used to do stupid things is over," he said.
In a Uganda where eccentric political actions are never in scarcity, many might find that assessment inaccurate.
Besides, that the leader of opposition can edit his own opinion to say what he does not believe shows how cowed politicians on both sides of the divide have become.
For the same Prof Latigo, on December 7, barely five days before, had indicated to a gathering of Uganda British Alumni Association that conditions prevailing in Uganda today are quite similar to those during the Chogm of 1971 when Idi Amin overthrew Milton Obote.
Addressing the UBAA dinner as guest of honour Prof Latigo said like the construction boom in Kampala today, Uganda's economy in 1971 was booming, the infrastructure excellent and the social services the envy of all Africa but that did not stop multitudes to pour into the streets to celebrate the toppling of the government by a soldier.
What is clearly hard to argue against therefore is that, for a typical Ugandan soldier power does not necessarily belong to the people, as the Constitution otherwise states in article 1.
KAMPALA
On a September 5th 2007 visit to Dwaniro, Kiboga District in central Uganda which hosted one of the rearguard bases for his vicious National Resistance Army, NRA insurgency against the UPC government (1981-85), President Yoweri Museveni let slip past his mouth a chilling revelation.
"If you had not elected us in 1996 and had not given us the mandate, we would have gone back to the bush to fight," Mr Museveni was quoted by national media on September 7 as telling the gathered peasants.
Perhaps it was tactical that Mr Museveni had chosen a rural setting, and an audience that could hardly perceive the extraordinary import of his statements to deliver what might be the most telling clue to the mindset and character of the NRA and its offspring, the UDPF.
Even if they had lost the election, Mr Museveni declared, they (him and his soldiers, the NRA) could never have allowed the "killers" who he said had backed DP's Paul Kawanga Ssemogerere, to come to power.
The inference from Mr Museveni's revelation was that the army and its Commander-in-Chief were unwilling to cede power regardless of Ugandans' choice. That was only a year after Uganda had gotten a new Constitution with free and fair elections as one of its sacrosanct principles.
"In simple English: Mr Museveni would have overthrown the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda," Dr Muniini Mulera a regular commentator on Uganda's politics said.
And this is the possibility we seek to explore in the second part of our series which delves into whether the UPDF would ever allow a civilian to assume power in case the incumbent slipped into incapacitation.
In the formal and automated process of national governance, succession in such a scenario is pretty straightforward and clear: the Vice President (currently Prof. Gilbert Bukenya) would assume office. But in the cold and brutal realities of Ugandan politics, succession never seems to follow a standard path, as is much of Sub-Saharan Africa.
And so, it's never a given as our Constitution suggests that power would automatically flow where it's supposed to if the presidency suddenly falls vacant. It all really hinges on how the army, the single force that has historically directed the course of power in independent Uganda, will act or not act.
"Ours is to respect the rule of law," insisted UPDF spokesperson, Maj. Felix Kulayigye in an interview on December 11. "Subject to the Constitution, we'll submit to whoever is in power as long as he's there legally."
The genteel and thoughtful Internal Affairs Minister, Dr Ruhakana Rugunda, too sees any suggestion of a possible UPDF interference in the succession process as mere conjecture.
But his optimism derives from a basic assumption. "The question of succession is a small point," he told Daily Monitor on December 12. "Because it has been well sorted out by the Constitution."
Still, beyond the assertions of Maj. Kulayigye and Dr Rugunda, there is a lot for Ugandans to fret about. The history of UPDF is not a history of virtue and patriotism.
Threats
In the heat of the 2001 presidential election campaigns, the current Coordinator of Intelligence Agencies in Uganda, Gen. David Tinyefuza, infamously declared that he would not submit to Dr Kiiza Besigye if the latter won the presidency.
And the former Director General of the Internal Security Organisation, Brig. Henry Tumukunde, reminded voters that whatever they did, Mr Museveni would still rule because they still had their guns.
Although such statements from serving (and senior) army officers would appear to carry a treasonable intent, there was never so much as a verbal reprimand from the army leadership then: corroborating what Mr Museveni implied later in Dwaniro - only the will of the army would really determine who rules Uganda.
Obviously, Gen. Tinyefuza's and Brig. Tumukunde's utterances are starkly incongruous with Maj. Kulayigye and Dr Rugunda's assertions of UPDF being a professional army, ready to submit to whichever Commander-in-Chief Ugandans (the people) may chose. Another incident, too, does undermine the glowing portrayals of UPDF.
On February 15, 2006, Lt. Ramathan Magara shot into a crowd of Dr Kiiza Besigye supporters at Bulange, Mengo, killing two people and permanently maiming a third. That tragedy, by a soldier during multiparty election campaigns, drew nationwide outrage and became a timeless stain on the UPDF.
But to the consternation of many, Lt. Magara was never court-martialled. The army instead disowned him and he was later charged in a civilian court and promptly granted bail, virtually leaving him a free man.
Lt. Magala killings
That a soldier could orchestrate such gruesome violence against an opponent of Mr Museveni, and he's even defended by elements in government (an RDC, Mr Fred Bamwine did) again underlines that faceless but decisive role of the army in determining Uganda's president.
True, Maj. Kulaigye's explanation initially sounds firm. "He's a civilian. He was retired from the army and so we couldn't try him."
But then it is Mr Museveni who invented a solution for civilians that use instruments that are a preserve of the army: court-martial. Lt. Magara used an AK 47 to murder the civilians, a weapon never licensed for civilian defence and only used by the security forces.
That is the government's justification to subject whoever handles an AK47 in Uganda to military law. How stupefying then that a 'retired' soldier could take up an AK 47, unleash a bloodbath and be spared a court-martial? Instead, since his release, Lt. Magara has claimed to be a representative of the President at one function.
Also telling is the army's feeling of entitlement to a major political role in Uganda. Even after constitutional amendments to suit the multiparty system, the army, about 50,000 strong, still maintains 10 seats in Parliament, even though all 10 are supposed to have only one view.
Clearly, the army sees itself as far more important than the rest of the population for at their ratio of parliamentary representation of 1:5000, Uganda's Parliament would have 6,000 MPs for a population of 30 million, if the civilian citizens were deemed to be equal to the soldiers in importance.
But to the leader of the Opposition, Prof Morris Ogenga Latigo, fears of UPDF hijacking power in case their current Commander-in-Chief got incapacitated in office are naïve. Coup d'états, he said on December 12, are anachronistic. "Time when soldiers used to do stupid things is over," he said.
In a Uganda where eccentric political actions are never in scarcity, many might find that assessment inaccurate.
Besides, that the leader of opposition can edit his own opinion to say what he does not believe shows how cowed politicians on both sides of the divide have become.
For the same Prof Latigo, on December 7, barely five days before, had indicated to a gathering of Uganda British Alumni Association that conditions prevailing in Uganda today are quite similar to those during the Chogm of 1971 when Idi Amin overthrew Milton Obote.
Addressing the UBAA dinner as guest of honour Prof Latigo said like the construction boom in Kampala today, Uganda's economy in 1971 was booming, the infrastructure excellent and the social services the envy of all Africa but that did not stop multitudes to pour into the streets to celebrate the toppling of the government by a soldier.
What is clearly hard to argue against therefore is that, for a typical Ugandan soldier power does not necessarily belong to the people, as the Constitution otherwise states in article 1.
Thursday, November 22, 2007
Commonwealth Business Forum: Lofty Goals, Little Impact.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--Often when accomplished business leaders converge, as in the just concluded Commonwealth Business Forum, CBF at Sheraton Hotel the ideas and issues under discussion tend to be of the highbrow sort. And why not, after all it's business that makes the world grind on. It’s business that makes societies and nations more powerful than others.
Just as a clue to the grandiosity of this business gathering (November 20th-22nd); the marquee to accommodate the over 700 delegates was hired at $400,000 from Dubai.
But don't be deceived by that and feel a great loss in case you've been unable to attend. In fact if you have ever attended any or participated in the CBF, the sense of déjà vu that you feel as you sit in the sessions can be overwhelming.
The Forum opened at 10 AM on Tuesday, November 20th with a speech by President Museveni. Any Ugandan delegate in there could as well have slept through the president's speech, and then woken up and still accurately recounted what he had told the Forum.
Reuters's correspondent, Tim Cocks quoted Museveni as saying, "We have confined ourselves to the export of raw materials such as coffee, where we have been getting $1 per kg while Nestle in London is getting $20 per kg."
But Mr. Cocks could easily have been accused of plagiarism because that's the same exact line that has run in thousands of stories on Museveni and his economic views.
As is well known of what happens when Museveni meets business executives, somehow the talk has to invariably feature his standard themes: value addition; donation of value to Western nations; Western investors’ failure to recognise Africa’s potential; his wisdom in attracting processors of our commodities; Uganda having the best bananas in the world and suchlike.
That would not necessarily be a problem since, as a head of state, his glib musings will always have an audience. The problem is the precious time lost in such trite talk which would otherwise have been better devoted to exploration of more thoughtful and intellectually stimulating ideas.
But may be we're being harsh on Museveni.
The droves of CEOs and economic policy directors at the CBF didn’t fair any better in terms of the freshness of debate and talking points. Almost all the subjects discussed at the CBF are the types on which you have probably attended half a dozen workshops or so. One such one was, "Leveraging ICT for Business Development." An even more stale one was, "enhancing intra-African trade," that was discussed by a seemingly powerful posse of business executives: Dr Yvonne Muthien, Director Special Projects, Coca-Cola, Africa; Jeremy Pike, Area Director, Sub Saharan Africa, BAT and Sir John Kaputin, ACP Secretary General. But the feeling one got after the debate session suggested that power was actually in titles not in their ideas.
In fact the only new element in the deliberations at the CBF was the personalities that tackled these subjects. But that didn’t necessarily make for a higher quality of debate. A Ugandan Journalist, Mr. Daniel Kalinaki of Kalinaki.blogspot.com derided the sessions as “boring,” and suggested that it was a great deal of pain to seat through any of them.
Nevertheless, some subjects that are new to global business discourses did generate a health and educative debate. The unfolding impact of climate change was such a one. A three-member panel—Mr. James Smith, Chairman of Shell, UK, Bobby Godsell, Director Anglo American, South Africa and Mr Reto Schwarwiler, Head of Global Government Relations, Swiss Re, Switzerland—delivered stimulating insights into this emerging threat to the economic prosperity of nations.
The recent floods that pummelled Uganda’s north, north-eastern and central regions in August and September displaced hundreds of thousands and destroyed infrastructure worth billions of shillings. Although debate about the link between global warming and extreme weather incidents is still continuing, there’s already a broad consensus among scientists that rising temperatures might be behind the increasingly frequent flooding ravaging tropical countries.
Hopefully Ugandan government officials at the CBF took this panel’s lessons to heart and will also possibly review some of the policies like allocating of forests to sugar cane and palm oil investors.
Kampala--Often when accomplished business leaders converge, as in the just concluded Commonwealth Business Forum, CBF at Sheraton Hotel the ideas and issues under discussion tend to be of the highbrow sort. And why not, after all it's business that makes the world grind on. It’s business that makes societies and nations more powerful than others.
Just as a clue to the grandiosity of this business gathering (November 20th-22nd); the marquee to accommodate the over 700 delegates was hired at $400,000 from Dubai.
But don't be deceived by that and feel a great loss in case you've been unable to attend. In fact if you have ever attended any or participated in the CBF, the sense of déjà vu that you feel as you sit in the sessions can be overwhelming.
The Forum opened at 10 AM on Tuesday, November 20th with a speech by President Museveni. Any Ugandan delegate in there could as well have slept through the president's speech, and then woken up and still accurately recounted what he had told the Forum.
Reuters's correspondent, Tim Cocks quoted Museveni as saying, "We have confined ourselves to the export of raw materials such as coffee, where we have been getting $1 per kg while Nestle in London is getting $20 per kg."
But Mr. Cocks could easily have been accused of plagiarism because that's the same exact line that has run in thousands of stories on Museveni and his economic views.
As is well known of what happens when Museveni meets business executives, somehow the talk has to invariably feature his standard themes: value addition; donation of value to Western nations; Western investors’ failure to recognise Africa’s potential; his wisdom in attracting processors of our commodities; Uganda having the best bananas in the world and suchlike.
That would not necessarily be a problem since, as a head of state, his glib musings will always have an audience. The problem is the precious time lost in such trite talk which would otherwise have been better devoted to exploration of more thoughtful and intellectually stimulating ideas.
But may be we're being harsh on Museveni.
The droves of CEOs and economic policy directors at the CBF didn’t fair any better in terms of the freshness of debate and talking points. Almost all the subjects discussed at the CBF are the types on which you have probably attended half a dozen workshops or so. One such one was, "Leveraging ICT for Business Development." An even more stale one was, "enhancing intra-African trade," that was discussed by a seemingly powerful posse of business executives: Dr Yvonne Muthien, Director Special Projects, Coca-Cola, Africa; Jeremy Pike, Area Director, Sub Saharan Africa, BAT and Sir John Kaputin, ACP Secretary General. But the feeling one got after the debate session suggested that power was actually in titles not in their ideas.
In fact the only new element in the deliberations at the CBF was the personalities that tackled these subjects. But that didn’t necessarily make for a higher quality of debate. A Ugandan Journalist, Mr. Daniel Kalinaki of Kalinaki.blogspot.com derided the sessions as “boring,” and suggested that it was a great deal of pain to seat through any of them.
Nevertheless, some subjects that are new to global business discourses did generate a health and educative debate. The unfolding impact of climate change was such a one. A three-member panel—Mr. James Smith, Chairman of Shell, UK, Bobby Godsell, Director Anglo American, South Africa and Mr Reto Schwarwiler, Head of Global Government Relations, Swiss Re, Switzerland—delivered stimulating insights into this emerging threat to the economic prosperity of nations.
The recent floods that pummelled Uganda’s north, north-eastern and central regions in August and September displaced hundreds of thousands and destroyed infrastructure worth billions of shillings. Although debate about the link between global warming and extreme weather incidents is still continuing, there’s already a broad consensus among scientists that rising temperatures might be behind the increasingly frequent flooding ravaging tropical countries.
Hopefully Ugandan government officials at the CBF took this panel’s lessons to heart and will also possibly review some of the policies like allocating of forests to sugar cane and palm oil investors.
At a C’wealth Gathering, Kutesa’s Diplomatic Flair is Seen as Phoney.
At a C’wealth Gathering, Kutesa’s Diplomatic Flair is Seen as Phoney.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--The Commonwealth Business Forum, CBF, one of the prominent meetings that precede the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, Chogm, opened on November 20th, 2007 at Sheraton Hotel in Kampala.
A number of officials both from the Ugandan government and the Commonwealth gave speeches before the final one by President Museveni who flagged off the Forum. Among them was Uganda’s Foreign Minister, Mr. Sam Kutesa known widely as one of the most powerful and influential (and wealthiest) ministers in Museveni’s government.
His speech was, unsurprisingly, low on substance: just about the kind that you would expect from any minister in the NRM government: they typically feature simplistic, generic remarks, shallowness of thought and frequent interjections with Dear-Leader-style praises of President Museveni.
So there was nothing remarkable in Kutesa’s speech and no body had a problem with that because no body expected anything better.
What shocked most Ugandans and the foreign delegates in attendance alike was the sudden trembling of Kutesa’s voice with the wavering worsening toward the end of his speech. There was total silence in the Grand Marquee where the CBF was hosted and so Kutesa’s wavy voice quickly caught the attention of many.
If a CEO of a small concern in Uganda or elsewhere had been intimidated by the powerful gathering (there were two presidents, Rwanda’s Paul Kagame being the second) and started shaking or losing control of himself, it would have been perfectly understandable.
But this was Sam Kutesa; a lawyer, a former Attorney General and one of the longest serving ministers in Museveni’s government. And most important: he’s Uganda’s top diplomat. He has met and talked with presidents, he’s travelled the globe and he has stood before and addressed some of most awesome audiences. On September 20th, 2006 for instance he addressed a gathering of world leaders at the UN headquarters in New York justifying Uganda’s granting of amnesty to the LRA leaders indicted by the ICC. So why did his diplomatic skills and composure fall apart at his most hour need?
Perhaps one would possibly sympathise with him if he was talking off the top of his head. But Kutesa was reading a prepared text.
I have since been asking myself why Kutesa cowered before an audience and I don’t seem to have hit an answer yet. But other questions, too, started popping up in mind: how then is Kutesa able to for instance square off with other foreign ministers or governments when conducting Uganda’s diplomatic business?
A foreign policy, for any nation, is one of the cardinal pillars of statehood. Foreign Ministers (or Secretaries) are typically the standard-bearers of nations’ foreign policies. Unmistakably common among them is their erudition, impeccable eloquence and finesse of personality.
Kutesa’s performance at the CBF showed an astonishing lack of any of these, casting his ability to steward Uganda’s Foreign Policy in deep doubt. One clue though may help us gain some understanding of Kutesa’s personality and why he didn’t shine at a moment he was supposed to.
On August 23rd this year, the Weekly Observer in a lead story, “US Firm Paid 2bn To Edit Museveni, Kutesa Letters,” reported that US’s ex Assistant Trade Representative for Africa, Ms Rosa Whitaker had earned thousands of dollars for assignments that included one where her firm edited Kutesa’s letter to the Editor of a US magazine, Foreign Policy. The letter was rebutting scorching charges by former UN Special Representative for children in armed conflict Mr. Olara Otunnu carried in an article “The Secret Genocide,” that was published around the world.
Any person with a reasonable command of English can read any article in any of our daily English newspapers and if he/she has any issues to raise or communicate regarding that article he can instantly write a letter to the editor. This is what ordinary Ugandans do on a daily basis to the letters’ editors of all our newspapers and that’s standard practice across the globe.
There’s absolutely no need for intermediaries and even if you hired one, it’s no guarantee that your letter will be given any priority over others. Selection of Letters for publication is done on merit.
But what then are we to make of the revelation that a whole minister, Mr. Sam Kutesa with such a “weighty” profile was incapable of personally composing a simple letter to the editor of Foreign Policy magazine?
That could be an important indicator of the level of sophistication of Mr. Kutesa and all these Professors and PhD ministers that populate Mr. Museveni’s cabinet.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--The Commonwealth Business Forum, CBF, one of the prominent meetings that precede the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, Chogm, opened on November 20th, 2007 at Sheraton Hotel in Kampala.
A number of officials both from the Ugandan government and the Commonwealth gave speeches before the final one by President Museveni who flagged off the Forum. Among them was Uganda’s Foreign Minister, Mr. Sam Kutesa known widely as one of the most powerful and influential (and wealthiest) ministers in Museveni’s government.
His speech was, unsurprisingly, low on substance: just about the kind that you would expect from any minister in the NRM government: they typically feature simplistic, generic remarks, shallowness of thought and frequent interjections with Dear-Leader-style praises of President Museveni.
So there was nothing remarkable in Kutesa’s speech and no body had a problem with that because no body expected anything better.
What shocked most Ugandans and the foreign delegates in attendance alike was the sudden trembling of Kutesa’s voice with the wavering worsening toward the end of his speech. There was total silence in the Grand Marquee where the CBF was hosted and so Kutesa’s wavy voice quickly caught the attention of many.
If a CEO of a small concern in Uganda or elsewhere had been intimidated by the powerful gathering (there were two presidents, Rwanda’s Paul Kagame being the second) and started shaking or losing control of himself, it would have been perfectly understandable.
But this was Sam Kutesa; a lawyer, a former Attorney General and one of the longest serving ministers in Museveni’s government. And most important: he’s Uganda’s top diplomat. He has met and talked with presidents, he’s travelled the globe and he has stood before and addressed some of most awesome audiences. On September 20th, 2006 for instance he addressed a gathering of world leaders at the UN headquarters in New York justifying Uganda’s granting of amnesty to the LRA leaders indicted by the ICC. So why did his diplomatic skills and composure fall apart at his most hour need?
Perhaps one would possibly sympathise with him if he was talking off the top of his head. But Kutesa was reading a prepared text.
I have since been asking myself why Kutesa cowered before an audience and I don’t seem to have hit an answer yet. But other questions, too, started popping up in mind: how then is Kutesa able to for instance square off with other foreign ministers or governments when conducting Uganda’s diplomatic business?
A foreign policy, for any nation, is one of the cardinal pillars of statehood. Foreign Ministers (or Secretaries) are typically the standard-bearers of nations’ foreign policies. Unmistakably common among them is their erudition, impeccable eloquence and finesse of personality.
Kutesa’s performance at the CBF showed an astonishing lack of any of these, casting his ability to steward Uganda’s Foreign Policy in deep doubt. One clue though may help us gain some understanding of Kutesa’s personality and why he didn’t shine at a moment he was supposed to.
On August 23rd this year, the Weekly Observer in a lead story, “US Firm Paid 2bn To Edit Museveni, Kutesa Letters,” reported that US’s ex Assistant Trade Representative for Africa, Ms Rosa Whitaker had earned thousands of dollars for assignments that included one where her firm edited Kutesa’s letter to the Editor of a US magazine, Foreign Policy. The letter was rebutting scorching charges by former UN Special Representative for children in armed conflict Mr. Olara Otunnu carried in an article “The Secret Genocide,” that was published around the world.
Any person with a reasonable command of English can read any article in any of our daily English newspapers and if he/she has any issues to raise or communicate regarding that article he can instantly write a letter to the editor. This is what ordinary Ugandans do on a daily basis to the letters’ editors of all our newspapers and that’s standard practice across the globe.
There’s absolutely no need for intermediaries and even if you hired one, it’s no guarantee that your letter will be given any priority over others. Selection of Letters for publication is done on merit.
But what then are we to make of the revelation that a whole minister, Mr. Sam Kutesa with such a “weighty” profile was incapable of personally composing a simple letter to the editor of Foreign Policy magazine?
That could be an important indicator of the level of sophistication of Mr. Kutesa and all these Professors and PhD ministers that populate Mr. Museveni’s cabinet.
Sunday, November 18, 2007
Chogm2007: International Media Picks the "Wrong Story!".
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA.
Kampala--Kampalans are agog! After all, haven’t their city been transformed over night into a World Class metropolis. Well, at least that’s the impression of many across central Uganda where the Chogm bonanza has impacted most.
It’s been a breathtaking makeover: roads have been smoothened, pavements laid. Medians have been planted with grass. Garbage mounds have disappeared. Messy intersections have been rebuilt and traffic lights fixed. Cameras are recording, and deterring crime, SPCs are roaming the city to the point of over-policing. Streets are lit. Five-Star hotel towers are shooting through the city’s skyline.
Entebbe airport is dazzling, abuzz with activity.
The world is descending on Kampala.
For once, President Museveni seems to have succeeded in putting Uganda in a global spotlight, right?
So why isn’t the international media picking up this great story unfolding in our city? This is the tale that is even more amazing to watch than the proceedings in the hallowed conference rooms in Munyonyo and Serena Hotels this week.
If president Museveni thought he and his NRM government would somehow harvest some political capital from the global media coverage of Chogm, he will be disappointed that the scribes have their eyes and ears on something else. In fact if the Western media’s disinterest in the ongoing Kampala Chogm2007 fever is a reflection of their disenchantment with Museveni and his government, then it’s pretty worrying indeed.
When the Commonwealth Youth Forum, the first of the major meetings that preceded Chogm got underway last week in Entebbe, it didn’t generate a world headline. Instead the French newswire AFP hollered to the world on Saturday, November17th; “Floods Deluge Uganda Capital, Kill Four.”
The online edition of BBC, the western media house with the broadest coverage of African news and supposedly with the keenest interest in the Commonwealth affairs has largely ignored the chogm frenzy in Kampala. And as if to demonstrate the triviality of the chogm euphoria in Kampala or even their loathing for the organiser-in-chief, they quickly picked up a gutter story run in local papers on November 14th, “Love Zones Set up in Kampala,” in reference to the restricting of whores to Kabalagala and Bukoto suburbs.
But if the BBC was mean, the Sunday Telegraph of UK gave Museveni a generous early Chogm gift. From Lira, their correspondent, Mr Mike Pflanz reported on November 18th, “Uganda’s £70 million Conference, £7 million Flood Relief.” The reporter sounded out the agonies of half a dozen starving flood victims slamming their government for spending so profligately on a useless meeting while its citizens were collapsing from hunger in sordid camps.
The report described Uganda as “poverty-wracked.”
For the whole of this year, president Museveni and his ministers have been quick to dismiss those criticising the splurging of vast amounts of money on a seemingly inconsequential meeting as blind.
Chogm, they have claimed, will “showcase Uganda’s rich potential to the World,” and draw in investors in their droves.
But the world’s businessmen and women reading the cries of the dying in the Sunday Telegraph story will probably first ponder the wisdom (or lack of it) of those of ruling the country before they inquire about the investment opportunities in Uganda, if they ever will.
In fact the Sunday Telegraph story mirrors the sort of questions and ideas that will run through the minds of the thousands of scribes jetting into the country this week. From the comfort of their hotels they will stroll around in the vicinity and see Nile Avenue, Garden City, Jinja Road intersection, Kampala Road: it’s a decent city.
But they know that’s not Kampala. Before they came they read up on Uganda’s online country profiles. They know Uganda’s GDP is a miniscule $8 billion and income per capita, a humiliating $230. They know Museveni bribed parliament to lift term limits so he could stay in power. They know Kampala is home to hordes of poor. They will look for them in Katwe, in Namuwongo, Kibuli and other slums. IDPs in northern Uganda will cry out and they will grab better headlines than the banquets and political rhetoric in Kampala.
That will be Museveni’s chogm media publicity harvest.
In the Western media; it will be the IDPs that that Museveni has betrayed, the dying flood victims in North East and the foolishness of the chogm extravagance that will run in banner headlines, not his taking of the Commonwealth chairmanship.
Kampala--Kampalans are agog! After all, haven’t their city been transformed over night into a World Class metropolis. Well, at least that’s the impression of many across central Uganda where the Chogm bonanza has impacted most.
It’s been a breathtaking makeover: roads have been smoothened, pavements laid. Medians have been planted with grass. Garbage mounds have disappeared. Messy intersections have been rebuilt and traffic lights fixed. Cameras are recording, and deterring crime, SPCs are roaming the city to the point of over-policing. Streets are lit. Five-Star hotel towers are shooting through the city’s skyline.
Entebbe airport is dazzling, abuzz with activity.
The world is descending on Kampala.
For once, President Museveni seems to have succeeded in putting Uganda in a global spotlight, right?
So why isn’t the international media picking up this great story unfolding in our city? This is the tale that is even more amazing to watch than the proceedings in the hallowed conference rooms in Munyonyo and Serena Hotels this week.
If president Museveni thought he and his NRM government would somehow harvest some political capital from the global media coverage of Chogm, he will be disappointed that the scribes have their eyes and ears on something else. In fact if the Western media’s disinterest in the ongoing Kampala Chogm2007 fever is a reflection of their disenchantment with Museveni and his government, then it’s pretty worrying indeed.
When the Commonwealth Youth Forum, the first of the major meetings that preceded Chogm got underway last week in Entebbe, it didn’t generate a world headline. Instead the French newswire AFP hollered to the world on Saturday, November17th; “Floods Deluge Uganda Capital, Kill Four.”
The online edition of BBC, the western media house with the broadest coverage of African news and supposedly with the keenest interest in the Commonwealth affairs has largely ignored the chogm frenzy in Kampala. And as if to demonstrate the triviality of the chogm euphoria in Kampala or even their loathing for the organiser-in-chief, they quickly picked up a gutter story run in local papers on November 14th, “Love Zones Set up in Kampala,” in reference to the restricting of whores to Kabalagala and Bukoto suburbs.
But if the BBC was mean, the Sunday Telegraph of UK gave Museveni a generous early Chogm gift. From Lira, their correspondent, Mr Mike Pflanz reported on November 18th, “Uganda’s £70 million Conference, £7 million Flood Relief.” The reporter sounded out the agonies of half a dozen starving flood victims slamming their government for spending so profligately on a useless meeting while its citizens were collapsing from hunger in sordid camps.
The report described Uganda as “poverty-wracked.”
For the whole of this year, president Museveni and his ministers have been quick to dismiss those criticising the splurging of vast amounts of money on a seemingly inconsequential meeting as blind.
Chogm, they have claimed, will “showcase Uganda’s rich potential to the World,” and draw in investors in their droves.
But the world’s businessmen and women reading the cries of the dying in the Sunday Telegraph story will probably first ponder the wisdom (or lack of it) of those of ruling the country before they inquire about the investment opportunities in Uganda, if they ever will.
In fact the Sunday Telegraph story mirrors the sort of questions and ideas that will run through the minds of the thousands of scribes jetting into the country this week. From the comfort of their hotels they will stroll around in the vicinity and see Nile Avenue, Garden City, Jinja Road intersection, Kampala Road: it’s a decent city.
But they know that’s not Kampala. Before they came they read up on Uganda’s online country profiles. They know Uganda’s GDP is a miniscule $8 billion and income per capita, a humiliating $230. They know Museveni bribed parliament to lift term limits so he could stay in power. They know Kampala is home to hordes of poor. They will look for them in Katwe, in Namuwongo, Kibuli and other slums. IDPs in northern Uganda will cry out and they will grab better headlines than the banquets and political rhetoric in Kampala.
That will be Museveni’s chogm media publicity harvest.
In the Western media; it will be the IDPs that that Museveni has betrayed, the dying flood victims in North East and the foolishness of the chogm extravagance that will run in banner headlines, not his taking of the Commonwealth chairmanship.
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
A Wrenching Quandary: Can Black People Build Prosperous Societies?
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--Mr. Yoweri Museveni has a background of good education. A calm and well exposed man. Straight thinking and intelligent, his grasp of contemporary world affairs, including some quite complex stuff, is commendably firm.
For years he burned his young energies battling vile governments. Narrowly escaping death on occasions, he showed resolve, sacrifice, devotion to his people and a deep abhorrence for oppressive leadership. Sure. This man had no shortage of good qualities.
And yet, to the astonishment of history, Mr Yoweri Kaguta Museveni has still failed us. Twenty years at nation building have produced incompetence so shocking that some think a psychopathic illiterate, Idi Amin, did better work.
Uganda has been fairly stable long enough. The conditions for an economic takeoff have been there for 20 years. Mr. Museveni has enjoyed generous goodwill from nearly all the world’s rich governments. Their largesse has poured in ceaselessly and in hefty amounts.
Uganda should have taken off. We haven’t. We’re stuck. And so is Tanzania, Sudan, Ethiopia, Mali, Ghana, Burkina Faso, Kenya, Eritrea, Malawi, Congo Republic and pretty much all of Black Africa, excluding the region’s sole economic power, South Africa. This led me to pose a question to myself: can Black people build prosperous societies?
Just about every reason-from slavery, colonialism, neo-colonialism to inequitable world trade rules-cited for the backwardness of Black African nations has been so debunked by time that it has now become necessary to look beyond the realm of such contemporary explanations. The maddening inertia of Black people and the mystical forces that keep tramping down our nations, in fact, seem to have their roots deep within us, not from without as has been argued for decades.
Just about everywhere you look, evidence abounds. Vietnam suffered a war of colonial conquest and it was eventually subdued by France in 1884. For almost a decade, it again fought a devastating independence war until France was vanquished in 1954. And then came the epic battle of 1965 to 1973 with US military and its allies, seeking to squelch the North Vietnamese communists.
When the guns fell silent with the withdrawal of US troops in 1973 and the eventual fall of Saigon in 1975, the Vietnamese [death] toll stood at a horrifying three to four million. Diplomatically isolated, its economy shredded and its population maimed and traumatized on a scale unparalleled in any Black African nation (except DR Congo), Vietnam would seem to have no chance at success.
But just two and a half decades later, Vietnam is storming the world stage as an economic powerhouse. Its exports are flooding western nations; heavy and advanced manufacturing is thriving at a rapid pace. Its GDP, $258 billion, is having an average growth rate of 8%, the second highest in Asia after China. Europe had to put curbs on the country’s shoe exports after they nearly sunk much of the continent’s manufacturers.
According to a news report in New York Times on October 25, 2006, Vietnam now sells “nine times as much to Americans as it buys from there.” Since 1990, a space of 15 short years, Vietnam has pulled off one of the most stunning economic feats: reducing absolute poverty-World Bank standard: subsisting on $1 a day-from 51 to 8% of its population.
Back home here (Uganda), the sort of wars and the scale of devastation that Uganda has suffered since independence can hardly be said to be as crippling as the cataclysm that struck Vietnam.
This is true for many of the Black African nations. But the difference is staggering. Vietnam’s economy is roaring. Sub Saharan Africa is dead stuck known more for: constant disease outbreaks, emergency food relief appeals, civil strive, genocide, chronic corruption, flimsy or nonexistent infrastructure, constitution breaches, state failure than anything else. This disgusting state of affairs after, according to an estimate by South Africa’s Brenthurst Foundation, a colossal $580 billion worth of donor money has been poured into the region since independence. Why have the Vietnamese overcome their historical setbacks and prospered while Black Africans stagnated or regressed?
Or if we may ask another question: why is it that White people prosper wherever they settle while Black people head for the opposite direction. The British crown started asserting its colonial rule over small territories on the continent of Australia in 1788, taking several decades before it brought all the areas into a unified Australian colony.
Throngs of Europeans emigrated en masse and settled there throughout the 1800s. These émigrés went ahead, starting from really little or nothing, and established one of the world’s economic and military powers that is Australia today. The history of New Zealand, the other White country in the Southern Hemisphere, is pretty much the same.
Now contrast these nations with Haiti, the only black nation outside of Africa. It gained independence in 1804. It’s near the US, the richest market on earth and Haiti has a coastline unlike other African nations whose landlocked status is blamed for their underdevelopment. And fine, it has had a fairly brutal past but nowhere near Vietnam’s horrors. But what have our Haitian brothers made of these generous natural advantages: it remains the most backward country in the Western hemisphere, bound up by privation, cyclical coups, spasms of mayhem and blood-thirsty gangs. At home and away, that’s your Black people!
In fact Haiti is perhaps just about the best that we can achieve in nation building. Ethiopia never had colonialism. It registered impressively high levels of literacy as early as 1970, a fact a friend of mine brought to my attention recently. It has a rich and widely shared cultural heritage, a common ancestry. This should have propelled Ethiopia but see the shameful portrait of hunger and disease that this country projects to the world.
And so, to go back to that question that I have been chewing over and over again of late: can Black People build prosperous societies; I firmly believe the answer is a sad NO.
The dumbfounding incompetence of President Museveni thus is not a failure of an individual. It’s a failure of a people: Black People. Museveni only rose and touched our low ceiling. The shamefully limited achievement of his “fundamental change” regime thus should be interpreted in this cruel context.
Kampala--Mr. Yoweri Museveni has a background of good education. A calm and well exposed man. Straight thinking and intelligent, his grasp of contemporary world affairs, including some quite complex stuff, is commendably firm.
For years he burned his young energies battling vile governments. Narrowly escaping death on occasions, he showed resolve, sacrifice, devotion to his people and a deep abhorrence for oppressive leadership. Sure. This man had no shortage of good qualities.
And yet, to the astonishment of history, Mr Yoweri Kaguta Museveni has still failed us. Twenty years at nation building have produced incompetence so shocking that some think a psychopathic illiterate, Idi Amin, did better work.
Uganda has been fairly stable long enough. The conditions for an economic takeoff have been there for 20 years. Mr. Museveni has enjoyed generous goodwill from nearly all the world’s rich governments. Their largesse has poured in ceaselessly and in hefty amounts.
Uganda should have taken off. We haven’t. We’re stuck. And so is Tanzania, Sudan, Ethiopia, Mali, Ghana, Burkina Faso, Kenya, Eritrea, Malawi, Congo Republic and pretty much all of Black Africa, excluding the region’s sole economic power, South Africa. This led me to pose a question to myself: can Black people build prosperous societies?
Just about every reason-from slavery, colonialism, neo-colonialism to inequitable world trade rules-cited for the backwardness of Black African nations has been so debunked by time that it has now become necessary to look beyond the realm of such contemporary explanations. The maddening inertia of Black people and the mystical forces that keep tramping down our nations, in fact, seem to have their roots deep within us, not from without as has been argued for decades.
Just about everywhere you look, evidence abounds. Vietnam suffered a war of colonial conquest and it was eventually subdued by France in 1884. For almost a decade, it again fought a devastating independence war until France was vanquished in 1954. And then came the epic battle of 1965 to 1973 with US military and its allies, seeking to squelch the North Vietnamese communists.
When the guns fell silent with the withdrawal of US troops in 1973 and the eventual fall of Saigon in 1975, the Vietnamese [death] toll stood at a horrifying three to four million. Diplomatically isolated, its economy shredded and its population maimed and traumatized on a scale unparalleled in any Black African nation (except DR Congo), Vietnam would seem to have no chance at success.
But just two and a half decades later, Vietnam is storming the world stage as an economic powerhouse. Its exports are flooding western nations; heavy and advanced manufacturing is thriving at a rapid pace. Its GDP, $258 billion, is having an average growth rate of 8%, the second highest in Asia after China. Europe had to put curbs on the country’s shoe exports after they nearly sunk much of the continent’s manufacturers.
According to a news report in New York Times on October 25, 2006, Vietnam now sells “nine times as much to Americans as it buys from there.” Since 1990, a space of 15 short years, Vietnam has pulled off one of the most stunning economic feats: reducing absolute poverty-World Bank standard: subsisting on $1 a day-from 51 to 8% of its population.
Back home here (Uganda), the sort of wars and the scale of devastation that Uganda has suffered since independence can hardly be said to be as crippling as the cataclysm that struck Vietnam.
This is true for many of the Black African nations. But the difference is staggering. Vietnam’s economy is roaring. Sub Saharan Africa is dead stuck known more for: constant disease outbreaks, emergency food relief appeals, civil strive, genocide, chronic corruption, flimsy or nonexistent infrastructure, constitution breaches, state failure than anything else. This disgusting state of affairs after, according to an estimate by South Africa’s Brenthurst Foundation, a colossal $580 billion worth of donor money has been poured into the region since independence. Why have the Vietnamese overcome their historical setbacks and prospered while Black Africans stagnated or regressed?
Or if we may ask another question: why is it that White people prosper wherever they settle while Black people head for the opposite direction. The British crown started asserting its colonial rule over small territories on the continent of Australia in 1788, taking several decades before it brought all the areas into a unified Australian colony.
Throngs of Europeans emigrated en masse and settled there throughout the 1800s. These émigrés went ahead, starting from really little or nothing, and established one of the world’s economic and military powers that is Australia today. The history of New Zealand, the other White country in the Southern Hemisphere, is pretty much the same.
Now contrast these nations with Haiti, the only black nation outside of Africa. It gained independence in 1804. It’s near the US, the richest market on earth and Haiti has a coastline unlike other African nations whose landlocked status is blamed for their underdevelopment. And fine, it has had a fairly brutal past but nowhere near Vietnam’s horrors. But what have our Haitian brothers made of these generous natural advantages: it remains the most backward country in the Western hemisphere, bound up by privation, cyclical coups, spasms of mayhem and blood-thirsty gangs. At home and away, that’s your Black people!
In fact Haiti is perhaps just about the best that we can achieve in nation building. Ethiopia never had colonialism. It registered impressively high levels of literacy as early as 1970, a fact a friend of mine brought to my attention recently. It has a rich and widely shared cultural heritage, a common ancestry. This should have propelled Ethiopia but see the shameful portrait of hunger and disease that this country projects to the world.
And so, to go back to that question that I have been chewing over and over again of late: can Black People build prosperous societies; I firmly believe the answer is a sad NO.
The dumbfounding incompetence of President Museveni thus is not a failure of an individual. It’s a failure of a people: Black People. Museveni only rose and touched our low ceiling. The shamefully limited achievement of his “fundamental change” regime thus should be interpreted in this cruel context.
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Poverty to Persist In Uganda; Even With Oil—Expert Declares.
On Monday Oct. 29th, 2007 I was exclusively supplied a report on Uganda's unfolding petroleum industry. I wrote a story that tried to be as accurate as possible while at the same time placing issues in perspective and bringing a measure of intelligence to bear on key points in that report. BUT because our media is full of mediocre and naïve editors (check a commentary on Uganda’s media on this blog), they messed up the original copy. Here’s an adaptation of an article published in Daily Monitor on Oct 30, 2007, page 4.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--An independent assessment of Uganda’s burgeoning petroleum industry has cast deep doubt over its economic impact, widely trumpeted by President Museveni’s government as potentially profound.
Dr. Keith Myers who conducted research this month on the viability and possible scenarios of petroleum exploitation in Uganda has suggested in a report obtained by this blogger that Uganda’s reserves could be much more modest than has been reported.
Dr Myers is a founding partner of UK-based Richmond Energy Partners which specialises in provision of research and advice to financial investors in small petroleum companies the likes of which operate in Uganda. He’s also a member of the International Monetary Fund, IMF’s panel of fiscal experts.
His incredulity about the size Uganda’s reserves stems from what he called “a huge uncertainty” on how much oil can be recovered commercially from the Albertine Graben. Although the exploration companies—Heritage Oil Corp and Tullow Oil—have already made their reserve estimates, Dr Myers said their numbers were not “supported by data or relevant analogues.”
From the three substantive oil wells drilled so far (Mputa, Waraga and Nzizi), Tullow Oil has estimated its oil reserves of recoverable oil at between 100-250 million barrels while Heritage Oil Corp which has one well has hinted that theirs is much higher although they have not provided a solid figure.
The two companies are listed in London and Toronto and “good news,” from Uganda, Dr Myers said, automatically pushes up their market value, a fact that could entice the companies to manipulate figures of their reserves in the country.
Although he didn’t point to a possible inflation of the stated reserve figures, he said the government should conduct independent surveys and verification and produce their own reserve estimates so that data provided by the companies can be cross referenced.
Mr. Reuben Kashambuzi, the Commissioner for Petroleum Exploration and Production Department in Entebbe told Daily Monitor yesterday that the government geologists have their own estimates but that they can’t release them because that would invite legal liability. “If we announce our own estimates and they contradict theirs (exploration companies) and their share price plunges, they can sue us and we would pay them enormous amounts of money,” he said.
Even then, it was highly unlikely, he said, that the companies would engage in duplicity since it could, too, result in stock crushes once the falsehoods come to light.
Dampening the euphoria that has bubbled across the country since oil was struck at Mputa in Hoima early last year, Dr. Myers suggested that Uganda still has several years before it starts earning any petrol dollars.
“Oil development will require significant cross-border investment in export infrastructure for either crude oil or refined products,” he said. “Significant oil revenues are unlikely before 2015 at the earliest.”
He offered a range of factors for his conclusion foremost of which, he said, is the frustrating remoteness of the oil fields in Western Uganda which are 1,200 Kilometres from Mombasa, the nearest seaport. Worse still, the locality of the fields (Hoima) has no functioning transportation and utilities infrastructure, and erecting them will take time and tremendous amounts of money.
The nature of Uganda’s oil, too, is a significant setback. It’s waxy and solidifies at room temperatures which imply, he said, that the export pipeline to the coast would have to be heated, a project that will require billions of dollars.
Also, the limited size of Uganda’s market renders home refinement a futile venture, a fact that necessitates immediate need of crude export infrastructure. Uganda’s daily demand is estimated at 13,650 barrels worth of oil products a day while a commercial refinery would have to have a capacity of about 100,000 barrels per day.
Dr Myers’ research reveals that the impact of the petrol dollars on the material welfare of Ugandans might in fact be negligible, contradicting popular expectation that oil will do much in ending abject poverty which afflicts 40% of the population.
According to his calculations, if exploration proves a reserve capacity of 750-1000 million barrels and an export project is agreed on, then Uganda would be able to sustain a production rate of 100-150,000 barrels per day.
Assuming a population of 27 million people and crude price of $60 a barrel, such an output would translate into 1-2 barrels per person per year. “This would mean $36-72 in oil revenues per Ugandan per year assuming a government take of 60 percent (on every barrel of crude exported),” he said.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--An independent assessment of Uganda’s burgeoning petroleum industry has cast deep doubt over its economic impact, widely trumpeted by President Museveni’s government as potentially profound.
Dr. Keith Myers who conducted research this month on the viability and possible scenarios of petroleum exploitation in Uganda has suggested in a report obtained by this blogger that Uganda’s reserves could be much more modest than has been reported.
Dr Myers is a founding partner of UK-based Richmond Energy Partners which specialises in provision of research and advice to financial investors in small petroleum companies the likes of which operate in Uganda. He’s also a member of the International Monetary Fund, IMF’s panel of fiscal experts.
His incredulity about the size Uganda’s reserves stems from what he called “a huge uncertainty” on how much oil can be recovered commercially from the Albertine Graben. Although the exploration companies—Heritage Oil Corp and Tullow Oil—have already made their reserve estimates, Dr Myers said their numbers were not “supported by data or relevant analogues.”
From the three substantive oil wells drilled so far (Mputa, Waraga and Nzizi), Tullow Oil has estimated its oil reserves of recoverable oil at between 100-250 million barrels while Heritage Oil Corp which has one well has hinted that theirs is much higher although they have not provided a solid figure.
The two companies are listed in London and Toronto and “good news,” from Uganda, Dr Myers said, automatically pushes up their market value, a fact that could entice the companies to manipulate figures of their reserves in the country.
Although he didn’t point to a possible inflation of the stated reserve figures, he said the government should conduct independent surveys and verification and produce their own reserve estimates so that data provided by the companies can be cross referenced.
Mr. Reuben Kashambuzi, the Commissioner for Petroleum Exploration and Production Department in Entebbe told Daily Monitor yesterday that the government geologists have their own estimates but that they can’t release them because that would invite legal liability. “If we announce our own estimates and they contradict theirs (exploration companies) and their share price plunges, they can sue us and we would pay them enormous amounts of money,” he said.
Even then, it was highly unlikely, he said, that the companies would engage in duplicity since it could, too, result in stock crushes once the falsehoods come to light.
Dampening the euphoria that has bubbled across the country since oil was struck at Mputa in Hoima early last year, Dr. Myers suggested that Uganda still has several years before it starts earning any petrol dollars.
“Oil development will require significant cross-border investment in export infrastructure for either crude oil or refined products,” he said. “Significant oil revenues are unlikely before 2015 at the earliest.”
He offered a range of factors for his conclusion foremost of which, he said, is the frustrating remoteness of the oil fields in Western Uganda which are 1,200 Kilometres from Mombasa, the nearest seaport. Worse still, the locality of the fields (Hoima) has no functioning transportation and utilities infrastructure, and erecting them will take time and tremendous amounts of money.
The nature of Uganda’s oil, too, is a significant setback. It’s waxy and solidifies at room temperatures which imply, he said, that the export pipeline to the coast would have to be heated, a project that will require billions of dollars.
Also, the limited size of Uganda’s market renders home refinement a futile venture, a fact that necessitates immediate need of crude export infrastructure. Uganda’s daily demand is estimated at 13,650 barrels worth of oil products a day while a commercial refinery would have to have a capacity of about 100,000 barrels per day.
Dr Myers’ research reveals that the impact of the petrol dollars on the material welfare of Ugandans might in fact be negligible, contradicting popular expectation that oil will do much in ending abject poverty which afflicts 40% of the population.
According to his calculations, if exploration proves a reserve capacity of 750-1000 million barrels and an export project is agreed on, then Uganda would be able to sustain a production rate of 100-150,000 barrels per day.
Assuming a population of 27 million people and crude price of $60 a barrel, such an output would translate into 1-2 barrels per person per year. “This would mean $36-72 in oil revenues per Ugandan per year assuming a government take of 60 percent (on every barrel of crude exported),” he said.
Friday, October 26, 2007
Sub-Saharan Africa: An Author Sees a Hopeless Future And He’s Unapologetic
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
KAMAPALA
Kampala—Lately, as it appears, sub-Saharan African countries seem to be on the rebound. Conflagrations have been doused in much of the sub-continent and as peace takes a firm hold, economic stability has followed, bringing opportunity and better welfare to millions across the region.
The International Monetary Fund, IMF’s regional economic outlook for sub-Saharan Africa published on October 20th showed a glowing portrait of a region in the midst of an energetic transformation. Economic growth for the region, said the IMF, will average 6 percent in 2007 and 6.75 percent in 2008, which will be a remarkable rise of about nearly 2 percentage points from 2005’s five and a half percent.
“This would extend a period of very good performance,” said the IMF. “In recent years the region has seen its strongest growth and lowest inflation in more than three decades.”
Capital flows into Africa are at their highest levels since independence. Investment is flourishing—the World Investment Report said the continent attracted $36 billion in 2006, double 2004’s figure—creating jobs and boosting incomes. Export earnings for the region, too, have soared to unprecedented levels on the back of an explosive worldwide commodity boom, particularly oil.
Through the Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative, MDRI, engineered by multilateral donors (WB, IMF, African Development Bank, Paris Club) and the G8, most sub-Saharan African countries have had their crushing debts cancelled and more resources are now being funnelled into long-neglected economic infrastructures.
All this has reversed decades of a downward spiral and lifted Africa onto the first rung of the ladder to economic prosperity, Right?
Not quite. At least, according to afro-pessimists.
Dr. Jacob van der Veen, an afro pessimist par excellence believes the worst is in fact yet to come. Dr. van der Veen who has travelled extensively and worked in sub-Saharan Africa sees all of the latest wave of seeming economic vitality as another of those endless episodes when Africa has suddenly become luminous, showed convincing promise and appeared ready to climb out of poverty only to for it to explode and plunge as dramatically as it had brightened.
Powered by globalisation, information and communication technological breakthroughs and mass consumption, Mr van der Veen observes in his book, What Went Wrong With Africa, that “it is clear that on average people’s lives have improved, all over the world, on every continent.”
Except Africa—to be more precise, sub-Saharan Africa. To be sure, Mr van der Veen’s book, first published in Dutch in 2002 and translated in English in 2004, brings no new compelling ideas about the tragedy of Black Africa but it’s the scale of detail he gives his diagnosis of the crisis and the shocking (almost provocative) candour of his views on the continent’s future that makes it a gripping and invigorating read.
“Even a confirmed optimist would hesitate to predict that life in Africa will get better in the years ahead.” van der Veen writes. His despair and doomsday arguments, which echo the familiar themes of Western reportage on Africa and scholarly work by several other Western authors, drew consternation and a hostile reception at a public debate in Kampala organised by Acode (a policy advocacy NGO) on Oct. 24th.
Dr. Kayunga Simba and Mr. Mwagutsya Ndebesa, from Makerere University Departments of political science and history respectively and Mr. Bernard Tabaire, Daily Monitor’s Managing Editor (Weekend Editions) accused him of regurgitating old and discredited theories that suggested that there was something peculiarly African about sub-Saharan Africa’s economic stagnation and chaotic politics.
To their pique, van der Veen, instead of seeking to clear misconceptions that may arise from his gloomy assertions, pressed forward, declaring that there was “nothing to make him optimistic about sub-Saharan Africa, not even the robust economic growth rates trumpeted by the IMF and the oil bonanza that is stirring euphoria all across the region.
A good measure of the economic dynamism that sub-Saharan Africa has picked up lately is so tenuous that even van der Veen’s critics may grudgingly admit that Africa’s perils may not be overcome as yet. Take exports, for instance. Prices for oil, metals, timber, coffee, sugar and several others are currently shooting through the roof; pouring prodigious amounts of money into the sub- Saharan African economies. But sometime, as it happens with booms, the prices will come crushing, and when that happens the same economies will start to sound distress signals, anew.
In many ways van der Veen’s book is easy to stoke indignation in Africans, particularly coming from the West which Africans generally tend to hold responsible for all their predicaments.
The litany of accusations is endless. Europe colonised us, pillaged our resources and has since continued to stymie our economic progress through economic marginalisation in the global marketplace. The West often displays astonishing ignorance on the complexities of the African society. The West does not offer much aid and while it’s ever railing against the corruption of African leaders, it’s content to keep the loot stashed in their banks by the same leaders.
Participants in the discussion pointed all this out.
And more, the thicket of hurdles that tamps down black Africa and which form the core of van der Veen’s narrative, too, are all familiar: state patronage, corruption, strong tribal loyalties, aid, decaying and ineffective institutions, violent conflict etc.
Many in the debate found it insulting—arguably for a good reason—that that a great deal of these problems had receded in many of the sub-Saharan countries, apparently signalling better times for the region. And yet van der Veen was still insisting that this was not enough to warrant any optimism.
Asked after the debate what he made of the accusations of bias and ignorance, van der Veen suggested that it was in fact such attitudes that were the greatest hindrance to the region’s development.
“I have noticed for instance that Ugandans are complacent,” he said. “They seem to say, ‘ok we were so badly off but now we’re somewhere and we’re happy with that’ which is really shocking if you really know what it takes to transform a pre-modern nation like Uganda to a modern country.”
He’s also not optimistic, he said, because he finds Ugandans and Africans generally to be too un-ambitious, complacent, slow-paced and much obsessed with blaming others for their crises instead of seizing and shaping their own destiny.
“There’s no sense of urgency among Africans. I have seen that wherever I have gone in all of sub-Saharan Africa and that will not take your countries anywhere,” he said.
KAMAPALA
Kampala—Lately, as it appears, sub-Saharan African countries seem to be on the rebound. Conflagrations have been doused in much of the sub-continent and as peace takes a firm hold, economic stability has followed, bringing opportunity and better welfare to millions across the region.
The International Monetary Fund, IMF’s regional economic outlook for sub-Saharan Africa published on October 20th showed a glowing portrait of a region in the midst of an energetic transformation. Economic growth for the region, said the IMF, will average 6 percent in 2007 and 6.75 percent in 2008, which will be a remarkable rise of about nearly 2 percentage points from 2005’s five and a half percent.
“This would extend a period of very good performance,” said the IMF. “In recent years the region has seen its strongest growth and lowest inflation in more than three decades.”
Capital flows into Africa are at their highest levels since independence. Investment is flourishing—the World Investment Report said the continent attracted $36 billion in 2006, double 2004’s figure—creating jobs and boosting incomes. Export earnings for the region, too, have soared to unprecedented levels on the back of an explosive worldwide commodity boom, particularly oil.
Through the Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative, MDRI, engineered by multilateral donors (WB, IMF, African Development Bank, Paris Club) and the G8, most sub-Saharan African countries have had their crushing debts cancelled and more resources are now being funnelled into long-neglected economic infrastructures.
All this has reversed decades of a downward spiral and lifted Africa onto the first rung of the ladder to economic prosperity, Right?
Not quite. At least, according to afro-pessimists.
Dr. Jacob van der Veen, an afro pessimist par excellence believes the worst is in fact yet to come. Dr. van der Veen who has travelled extensively and worked in sub-Saharan Africa sees all of the latest wave of seeming economic vitality as another of those endless episodes when Africa has suddenly become luminous, showed convincing promise and appeared ready to climb out of poverty only to for it to explode and plunge as dramatically as it had brightened.
Powered by globalisation, information and communication technological breakthroughs and mass consumption, Mr van der Veen observes in his book, What Went Wrong With Africa, that “it is clear that on average people’s lives have improved, all over the world, on every continent.”
Except Africa—to be more precise, sub-Saharan Africa. To be sure, Mr van der Veen’s book, first published in Dutch in 2002 and translated in English in 2004, brings no new compelling ideas about the tragedy of Black Africa but it’s the scale of detail he gives his diagnosis of the crisis and the shocking (almost provocative) candour of his views on the continent’s future that makes it a gripping and invigorating read.
“Even a confirmed optimist would hesitate to predict that life in Africa will get better in the years ahead.” van der Veen writes. His despair and doomsday arguments, which echo the familiar themes of Western reportage on Africa and scholarly work by several other Western authors, drew consternation and a hostile reception at a public debate in Kampala organised by Acode (a policy advocacy NGO) on Oct. 24th.
Dr. Kayunga Simba and Mr. Mwagutsya Ndebesa, from Makerere University Departments of political science and history respectively and Mr. Bernard Tabaire, Daily Monitor’s Managing Editor (Weekend Editions) accused him of regurgitating old and discredited theories that suggested that there was something peculiarly African about sub-Saharan Africa’s economic stagnation and chaotic politics.
To their pique, van der Veen, instead of seeking to clear misconceptions that may arise from his gloomy assertions, pressed forward, declaring that there was “nothing to make him optimistic about sub-Saharan Africa, not even the robust economic growth rates trumpeted by the IMF and the oil bonanza that is stirring euphoria all across the region.
A good measure of the economic dynamism that sub-Saharan Africa has picked up lately is so tenuous that even van der Veen’s critics may grudgingly admit that Africa’s perils may not be overcome as yet. Take exports, for instance. Prices for oil, metals, timber, coffee, sugar and several others are currently shooting through the roof; pouring prodigious amounts of money into the sub- Saharan African economies. But sometime, as it happens with booms, the prices will come crushing, and when that happens the same economies will start to sound distress signals, anew.
In many ways van der Veen’s book is easy to stoke indignation in Africans, particularly coming from the West which Africans generally tend to hold responsible for all their predicaments.
The litany of accusations is endless. Europe colonised us, pillaged our resources and has since continued to stymie our economic progress through economic marginalisation in the global marketplace. The West often displays astonishing ignorance on the complexities of the African society. The West does not offer much aid and while it’s ever railing against the corruption of African leaders, it’s content to keep the loot stashed in their banks by the same leaders.
Participants in the discussion pointed all this out.
And more, the thicket of hurdles that tamps down black Africa and which form the core of van der Veen’s narrative, too, are all familiar: state patronage, corruption, strong tribal loyalties, aid, decaying and ineffective institutions, violent conflict etc.
Many in the debate found it insulting—arguably for a good reason—that that a great deal of these problems had receded in many of the sub-Saharan countries, apparently signalling better times for the region. And yet van der Veen was still insisting that this was not enough to warrant any optimism.
Asked after the debate what he made of the accusations of bias and ignorance, van der Veen suggested that it was in fact such attitudes that were the greatest hindrance to the region’s development.
“I have noticed for instance that Ugandans are complacent,” he said. “They seem to say, ‘ok we were so badly off but now we’re somewhere and we’re happy with that’ which is really shocking if you really know what it takes to transform a pre-modern nation like Uganda to a modern country.”
He’s also not optimistic, he said, because he finds Ugandans and Africans generally to be too un-ambitious, complacent, slow-paced and much obsessed with blaming others for their crises instead of seizing and shaping their own destiny.
“There’s no sense of urgency among Africans. I have seen that wherever I have gone in all of sub-Saharan Africa and that will not take your countries anywhere,” he said.
Labels:
IMF,
sub-Sarahan Africa,
van der Veen,
World Investment Report
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
Oil: The Americans Are Coming, And With Them, Trouble Galore
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala—In December 2000, the National Intelligence Council, a think-tank within United States’ CIA declared in a report that sub-Saharan Africa, “will play an increasing role in global energy markets,” according to John Ghazvinian in his 2007 book, Untapped, The Scramble For Africa’s Oil.
That observation set off a train of broad commercial and diplomatic maneuvering that has seen the US move decisively to counter China’s tightening grip on Africa’s energy resources.
The latest in this effort is a covert scheme designed to entrench US interests in Uganda’s burgeoning petroleum industry.
On 22nd Oct, the United States Trade and Development Agency, USTDA, announced that it had procured a U.S. consultant, RKR Enterprises, to begin exploring Uganda’s emerging petroleum and gas industry and advise on where the US may, “grant assistance.”
Often, the language used in such press statements, in keeping with the subtlety and complexity of Western diplomacy, is innocent enough.
“Potential actions that could result from the mission (the project),” said USTDA’s statement, “include technical assistance programs, feasibility studies, training activities, and/or orientation visits.”
Fair enough, you thought!
Not quite.
Implicit in the “technical assistance,” “capacity building,” “training activities,” and similar other phrases is a simple and urgent goal of guaranteeing a constant flow of resources (oil, minerals etc) from the aid recipient to the donor nation in question.
All the discoveries combined, Uganda now can (tentatively, because it’s at an exploratory level) produce about 32,000 barrels of oil per day, bopd. Exploration is continuing and the two frontline companies—Tullow Oil of UK and Heritage Corp of Canada—have hinted they will strike far greater reserves toward the northern tip of Lake Albert in Western in Uganda. Expectation is soaring, too, over the exploratory fields stretching far out toward West Nile.
Taken together thus, these developments illuminate the US’s real intentions in the sudden offer of “technical assistance,” to Uganda’s petroleum sector even before anyone has asked.
Its move is consonant with a recent wave of diplomatic overtures extended by China, India and other Asian nations all eager to carve out their share of the unfolding petroleum bounty.
Currently, competition is intensifying among the world’s major powers (US, China, India and EU) for the dwindling world petroleum resources. China has particularly upset the world’s energy balance as its demand for oil to fuel its industrial juggernaut has grown at a terrifying speed. Lately it has scrambled to redirect more of the flow of Africa’s oil towards itself, prompting a swift EU and American response in form of sweetened deals for greater economic cooperation and a boost in direct aid.
So what’s the upshot of all this and what really should concern an average Ugandan?
Well, start to get worried when the US gets entwined in Uganda’s unfolding oil politics. Eager to extract as much oil supply as possible, the US will basically leave Museveni to rule Ugandans as he pleases, as long as he doesn’t interfere with its petroleum interests.
With US diplomatic largess to underwrite his grip on power, a beefy treasury to purchase loyalty and purchase arms to brutalize opponents, Ugandans can expect to suffer under Museveni’s insanity for the next decade.
Kampala—In December 2000, the National Intelligence Council, a think-tank within United States’ CIA declared in a report that sub-Saharan Africa, “will play an increasing role in global energy markets,” according to John Ghazvinian in his 2007 book, Untapped, The Scramble For Africa’s Oil.
That observation set off a train of broad commercial and diplomatic maneuvering that has seen the US move decisively to counter China’s tightening grip on Africa’s energy resources.
The latest in this effort is a covert scheme designed to entrench US interests in Uganda’s burgeoning petroleum industry.
On 22nd Oct, the United States Trade and Development Agency, USTDA, announced that it had procured a U.S. consultant, RKR Enterprises, to begin exploring Uganda’s emerging petroleum and gas industry and advise on where the US may, “grant assistance.”
Often, the language used in such press statements, in keeping with the subtlety and complexity of Western diplomacy, is innocent enough.
“Potential actions that could result from the mission (the project),” said USTDA’s statement, “include technical assistance programs, feasibility studies, training activities, and/or orientation visits.”
Fair enough, you thought!
Not quite.
Implicit in the “technical assistance,” “capacity building,” “training activities,” and similar other phrases is a simple and urgent goal of guaranteeing a constant flow of resources (oil, minerals etc) from the aid recipient to the donor nation in question.
All the discoveries combined, Uganda now can (tentatively, because it’s at an exploratory level) produce about 32,000 barrels of oil per day, bopd. Exploration is continuing and the two frontline companies—Tullow Oil of UK and Heritage Corp of Canada—have hinted they will strike far greater reserves toward the northern tip of Lake Albert in Western in Uganda. Expectation is soaring, too, over the exploratory fields stretching far out toward West Nile.
Taken together thus, these developments illuminate the US’s real intentions in the sudden offer of “technical assistance,” to Uganda’s petroleum sector even before anyone has asked.
Its move is consonant with a recent wave of diplomatic overtures extended by China, India and other Asian nations all eager to carve out their share of the unfolding petroleum bounty.
Currently, competition is intensifying among the world’s major powers (US, China, India and EU) for the dwindling world petroleum resources. China has particularly upset the world’s energy balance as its demand for oil to fuel its industrial juggernaut has grown at a terrifying speed. Lately it has scrambled to redirect more of the flow of Africa’s oil towards itself, prompting a swift EU and American response in form of sweetened deals for greater economic cooperation and a boost in direct aid.
So what’s the upshot of all this and what really should concern an average Ugandan?
Well, start to get worried when the US gets entwined in Uganda’s unfolding oil politics. Eager to extract as much oil supply as possible, the US will basically leave Museveni to rule Ugandans as he pleases, as long as he doesn’t interfere with its petroleum interests.
With US diplomatic largess to underwrite his grip on power, a beefy treasury to purchase loyalty and purchase arms to brutalize opponents, Ugandans can expect to suffer under Museveni’s insanity for the next decade.
Tuesday, October 23, 2007
Jamwa & NSSF: Lots of Haze.
ELIAS BIRYABAREMA
Kampala--On October 4th, NSSF’s new management, flanked by the Board held a press briefing to apprise Ugandans on what has been going on since they assumed office and to lay out their vision for the Fund in the next five years.
It was a timely opportunity that the new Managing Director, Mr David Chandi Jamwa could have exploited to regain the trust and confidence of Ugandan workers and assure them that the brazen waste and mismanagement of their little savings had stopped.
But nothing of the sort transpired.
Instead, Mr. Jamwa, gruff-voiced and menacingly muscular, fired off to a false start, launching into a venomous and overreaching assault on all of NSSF’s critics and commentators. Then he got wild and insulted those who have suggested lowering of the age at which a person can legally access his/her savings to 40 from the current 55 years: describing them as, “verging on lunacy.”
Such a combative and arrogant approach is unwise and unhelpful for a leadership that is seeking to turn around the image and operations of an organisation as prone to scandal as NSSF. Mr. Jamwa doesn’t have a monopoly of ideas on how NSSF should be run. And he must be liberal enough to accommodate and benefit from the on going feisty public debate on how Uganda’s pensions sector can be cleaned up and graduated to a higher level of efficiency.
At the conference, NSSF announced that it would increase the rate of return on workers’ savings from the current 7% (which is below Uganda’s average inflation) to 12 percent over a period of five years. This was, NSSF said, “to stop the destruction and loss of value” of workers’ savings that has been the hallmark of the Fund for the last decade or so. In that sense Mr. Jamwa was in effect agreeing with NSSF’s critics who have advised that the nation’s pensions sector be opened up to competition so that workers can earn a market rate on their savings.
A rose by any other name smells just as sweet. Even if NSSF paid its members a 12% interest, a monopoly by any another name is a monopoly and it is bad. There’s no way workers can know whether they’re receiving the best benefits from NSSF: only the market can determine that. In any case, if NSSF is now intelligently run and efficient as Mr. Jamwa is declaring why then is he frightened by the idea of an open and competitive marketplace?
Something else, too, about Mr. Jamwa appeared to provide an unsettling clue into his leadership. When a hack inquired into the persisting mystery surrounding the Shs. 8 billion sunk into the infamous Nsimbe Housing Estate, Mr Jamwa declared that there was, “now value lost in Nsimbe.”
Throughout 2004 and 2005, it was reported widely that NSSF had purchased a chunk of land at Shs.8 billion, which was double the prevailing market price.
As the scam’s full breadth came to light, the then NSSF’s MD, Mr. Leonard Mpuma and the entire Board chaired by Mr. Onegi Obel were suspended. Both of them are currently undergoing trial for that fraud.
Now, in addition to the colossal loss ( estimated at Shs 4 billion) that NSSF incurred in the bloated cost of land; the Shs. 8 billion has been at best underutilised and at worst lying idle in the last two years—something of a no-brainer, I thought.
Yet here was Mr. Jamwa, unblinking, straight-faced, telling journalists and Ugandans that NSSF had not lost a coin in Nsimbe! There was little to conclude from this episode other than it being a pointer to the level of honesty and transparency that we should expect from the new powers at Workers House.
A good measure of the cynicism from workers and media directed at NSSF would seem justified.
Sometime in 2005, NSSF, in endless press statements told us that they had installed some new and costly software with an amazing range of abilities. It was developed by South Africa’s Face Technologies. Once fully functional, we were told, the software was supposed to end many of the deficiencies and delays in handling members’ data and processing of claims. Foremost among the benefits was that members were supposed to track their balances online and that a typical claim would now be processed in a maximum of two weeks, instead of months as was the case.
The software was also to help in cleaning up and better tracking of records and so reduce bogus or under valuing of savings.
We duly reported all this to Ugandans.
Two years down the road, that software, it appears, has not solved any of the woes besetting NSSF. The only beneficiary is FT which earned a premium on that bogus project.
Through all this, the sum picture emerging from Mr. Jamwa’s few months of leadership at NSSF, is not one of great hope. Nevertheless, he still has a chance to steer this behemoth to a better direction and leave behind a better record.
Kampala--On October 4th, NSSF’s new management, flanked by the Board held a press briefing to apprise Ugandans on what has been going on since they assumed office and to lay out their vision for the Fund in the next five years.
It was a timely opportunity that the new Managing Director, Mr David Chandi Jamwa could have exploited to regain the trust and confidence of Ugandan workers and assure them that the brazen waste and mismanagement of their little savings had stopped.
But nothing of the sort transpired.
Instead, Mr. Jamwa, gruff-voiced and menacingly muscular, fired off to a false start, launching into a venomous and overreaching assault on all of NSSF’s critics and commentators. Then he got wild and insulted those who have suggested lowering of the age at which a person can legally access his/her savings to 40 from the current 55 years: describing them as, “verging on lunacy.”
Such a combative and arrogant approach is unwise and unhelpful for a leadership that is seeking to turn around the image and operations of an organisation as prone to scandal as NSSF. Mr. Jamwa doesn’t have a monopoly of ideas on how NSSF should be run. And he must be liberal enough to accommodate and benefit from the on going feisty public debate on how Uganda’s pensions sector can be cleaned up and graduated to a higher level of efficiency.
At the conference, NSSF announced that it would increase the rate of return on workers’ savings from the current 7% (which is below Uganda’s average inflation) to 12 percent over a period of five years. This was, NSSF said, “to stop the destruction and loss of value” of workers’ savings that has been the hallmark of the Fund for the last decade or so. In that sense Mr. Jamwa was in effect agreeing with NSSF’s critics who have advised that the nation’s pensions sector be opened up to competition so that workers can earn a market rate on their savings.
A rose by any other name smells just as sweet. Even if NSSF paid its members a 12% interest, a monopoly by any another name is a monopoly and it is bad. There’s no way workers can know whether they’re receiving the best benefits from NSSF: only the market can determine that. In any case, if NSSF is now intelligently run and efficient as Mr. Jamwa is declaring why then is he frightened by the idea of an open and competitive marketplace?
Something else, too, about Mr. Jamwa appeared to provide an unsettling clue into his leadership. When a hack inquired into the persisting mystery surrounding the Shs. 8 billion sunk into the infamous Nsimbe Housing Estate, Mr Jamwa declared that there was, “now value lost in Nsimbe.”
Throughout 2004 and 2005, it was reported widely that NSSF had purchased a chunk of land at Shs.8 billion, which was double the prevailing market price.
As the scam’s full breadth came to light, the then NSSF’s MD, Mr. Leonard Mpuma and the entire Board chaired by Mr. Onegi Obel were suspended. Both of them are currently undergoing trial for that fraud.
Now, in addition to the colossal loss ( estimated at Shs 4 billion) that NSSF incurred in the bloated cost of land; the Shs. 8 billion has been at best underutilised and at worst lying idle in the last two years—something of a no-brainer, I thought.
Yet here was Mr. Jamwa, unblinking, straight-faced, telling journalists and Ugandans that NSSF had not lost a coin in Nsimbe! There was little to conclude from this episode other than it being a pointer to the level of honesty and transparency that we should expect from the new powers at Workers House.
A good measure of the cynicism from workers and media directed at NSSF would seem justified.
Sometime in 2005, NSSF, in endless press statements told us that they had installed some new and costly software with an amazing range of abilities. It was developed by South Africa’s Face Technologies. Once fully functional, we were told, the software was supposed to end many of the deficiencies and delays in handling members’ data and processing of claims. Foremost among the benefits was that members were supposed to track their balances online and that a typical claim would now be processed in a maximum of two weeks, instead of months as was the case.
The software was also to help in cleaning up and better tracking of records and so reduce bogus or under valuing of savings.
We duly reported all this to Ugandans.
Two years down the road, that software, it appears, has not solved any of the woes besetting NSSF. The only beneficiary is FT which earned a premium on that bogus project.
Through all this, the sum picture emerging from Mr. Jamwa’s few months of leadership at NSSF, is not one of great hope. Nevertheless, he still has a chance to steer this behemoth to a better direction and leave behind a better record.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)